AI overviews: why????

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Great...and I thought I didn't trust AI before...:(

Even ignoring the inevitable corruption of AI by money-making concerns...and of course, we can't ignore it... there's the simple problem of not using it and therefore losing it. I'm referring to human intelligence, instinct, perception. Today's thinking postulates that Neanderthals were extremely intelligent, with brains equal or superior to our own. A successful Neanderthal needed to know a lot of things about how to go about surviving. A modern human in our "enlightened" society can often get by with being expert in one small area of thought, and exploiting that knowledge to earn money that then buys or hires all the other things needed to function normally. Today's human doesn't need to be an expert hunter, fisherman, farmer, builder, warrior, healer, etc...he can master one area of expertise and then rely upon others to supply all he needs from their specialties. A typical human of today may be a whiz at computer programming, or electronics, or agricultural or whatever...but if circumstances suddenly forced him to survive entirely on his own abilities, skills and knowledge, he'd be dead in a month.

Robert Heinlein said that "specialization is for insects". He suggested that a well-rounded human should be capable of doing pretty much anything that dircumstances required of him to at least an acceptable degree.

If AI gets as good as some hope it will, or even as good as some think it already is...who needs brains anymore? We will have (d)evolved from being ultra-capable Jacks-of-all-trades...to specialized drones who can only do one thing really well...and then finally to useless dummies who can't do a dang thing for themselves, including thinking.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cal Amari
I just wanted to point out, that this thread is actually less than a year old. No AI required. :)
 
We will have (d)evolved from being ultra-capable Jacks-of-all-trades...to specialized drones who can only do one thing really well...and then finally to useless dummies who can't do a dang thing for themselves, including thinking.

John, in case you missed it, that train left the station a long time ago.
 
I know...but I continue to live in hope and denial...
 
Hello; An equivalent application of the Ai question might be self driving cars. The good sides are out of balance with the known bad sides. A self driving car likely makes millions of decisions during a trip. (I am guessing, may be billions of decisions) The one or two bad choices outweigh everything.

We justifiably expect a potentially life threating machine to be perfect or otherwise have safeguards around them. An industrial robot might be inside a cage for example. When a self-drive car screws up such may be one bad decision out of trillions of good decisions.
Saw a story of a self-drive car which slammed the brakes on because a bird flew across the road in front of its sensors. I guess a human had to be in the car or maybe a review of the camera images.
 
My bad, must have been a hallucination...
Nah...you probably just read it on AI (mistake #1)...and then believed it (mistake #2)! :)

Hello; An equivalent application of the Ai question might be self driving cars. The good sides are out of balance with the known bad sides. A self driving car likely makes millions of decisions during a trip. (I am guessing, may be billions of decisions) The one or two bad choices outweigh everything.
There was a movie recently called Leave The World Behind, focusing on the aftermath of a poorly-explained cyber-attack on the US that completely shut down the communications and infrastructure of the country. It was much-talked-about for a short time after it appeared. I personally didn't enjoy it at all...very woke, very weird, very vague...but one scene stood out:

A deserted road is clogged with cars, arranged in a long daisy-chain-reaction collision. Hundreds of cars, all the same colour, make and model of Tesla. Nobody in any of them. The protagonist has just discovered this strange spectacle and is trying to figure out how to get past it, when suddenly another identical driverless Tesla comes screaming up the road from behind him and smashes into the rear of the string of wrecked vehicles. He has just managed to avoid being struck by this new car and is still unsure of what has happened. Then yet another one hits, and then another, and another...every 60 seconds another driverless AI-piloted Tesla hits those in front going at full highway speed.

Contrast that to the future world posited by SF author Larry Niven. His meticulously-drawn future includes crowded cities that are full of flying "'cars" going every which way at various speeds and altitudes. All are driverless, fully operated and guided by AI. One of the few remaining capital offenses in this future is manually operating a flying vehicle over a city, due to the extreme potential for loss of life in the melee of vehicles in the air at all times.

Gee...I wonder if Larry saw that movie and what he thought of it...? :)
 
Hello; I have several Niven books & stories. Among my favorites are the ones about the MAN -KINZEN(sp) WARS.
I'm a Niven fan as well, have probably read all his stuff with the exception of the numerous collaborations he worked on with a handful of other SF writers. The Kzinti are among my favourites of his creations; they were the bad-asses of space, like the Klingons were to Star Trek. Tons of stories, all set in Niven's wonderful Known Space universe, spanning centuries of time, featuring recurring characters like Louis Wu, Gil Hamilton, Speaker-To-Animals, Nessus the Puppeteer, the Brennan-Monster, Rick Schumann, Teela Brown. Imaginative technology...jump booths, stasis fields, light sails, ringworlds, the list goes on. Interesting ideas like the discovery that Homo sapiens is merely the neotenic larval form of the Protector species. All this stuff entranced me when I was in my teens, still gives me a warm, somewhat setimental feeling now.

Makes me want to re-read the Ringworld novels...again...:)
 
Last edited:
MonsterFishKeepers.com