Thank you all for the opinions. I've kept plecos before so I'm not quite a newbie with them, they are well fed beyond the algae and I think I've only ever lost one and I never figured out why, it certainly wasn't a feeding issue.
If I recall right (from when I got my first poly, admittedly I didn't do a ton of research after the general consensus was caution), I think most of what I was reading was, in addition to the slime coat attraction, was a concern of the polys attempting to eat them tail first and catching their barbs. This is why I was considering a larger pleco. Is this an actual concern?