**ALL YOUR WATER PROBLEMS SOLVED**

[pi-eyed]

I've seen this product for salt and fresh. The instructions on the back start out saying that it doesn't matter if you have a 5g or a 55g. It sounds interesting but I'm with the op on this one. I'm interested to hear someones experience with this product. I'm not brave enough to even try this...IMO sounds like a gimmick.

Still curious,
Chris

 

[nonstophoops]

This industry is unregulated and anyone at any time can come out with a product claiming anything with no consequences. Most of the products out there are just a money maker and completely useless.

 

[Lupin]

You know that old saying.... If it sounds too good too be true......it probably isn't

Best answer.

 

[Wiggles92]

I think that I may have to set up another small saltwater aquarium in addition to my already planned one in order to test this in a scientific manner.

 

[Spontaneous]

It's to get all the salty newbs like me =D
But on a serious note... Someone like me who is just starting out but isn't getting awesome help from people like you guys are going to buy this and find it it does/doesn't work when all their fishies and corals die.

 

[LD50]

nothing can replace WCs

+1

I think I may go do an extra 'sympathy water change" in honor of all the tanks that are about to stop getting water changes.

Indeed, I was reading your other post about DOC's and I also wanted to point out other things that WC's do like replace trace elements... I know you can dose/test but that would require you to buy more stuff. A lot easier to buy some mix do a quick WC and not worry about it imo.

As for the snake oil I would go for it except for this little thing called The Law of Conservation of Mass . Bottom line, no matter how much you change/process mooky stank it stays there until you export it and a year long build up of mooky stank can NOT be good for the livestock, true story.

"You can polish a turd as much as you want, but it's still a turd" - Dad.

 

[FLESHY]

"You can polish a turd as much as you want, but it's still a turd" - Dad.

+2