another catfish pickup..brachyplatystoma platynema

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Both unfortunate. The first I housed with a tig, and they grew at about the same rate for about a year. The tig killed the platy one night. The other only made it about 6 months. The weiner dog unplugged the tank while I was out of town and the wife didn't notice it.
Yea, we are brothers in bad luck. Mine has just met its demise too, two days ago. I'm a fish hoarder, not keeper, and this is the price.

I've had it since Mar 2016, when I got it from John Gerber's in Dayton Ohio at about 8" for $200. Spent the first months trying to get it to eat cut fish and pellets. It did. Had to rehome it about 3 times between different 240 gal tanks because tank mates bothered it - other brachies, wels, etc. So I thought I'd take a risk and place it in "peaceful community" 4500 gal a week ago. It was ~10". It lasted 3-4 days. Its tail got tattered but it had happened dozens of times before. Then one evening I've found front half of it stuck on the drain screen. Heartbroken. What's worse is that in this big recent reshuffling I have got two 240 gal out of ten empty and could have put it there and no one would bother it anymore but thought it could be better in a 4500 gal because it likes to swim. I've no idea who killed it. I've seen fish "come say hi" and some fleeting interest from a 16" VATF but really IDK who killed it and ate the hind half and whether it was even the same fish.

Slobber is a timid fish. Never bothers others but others bother it. It was not the smallest or the weakest fish in the 4500 gal but someone definitely had a tooth for it. I also placed an 8" tig in there too at the same time along with a 10" one (and there is a 14" one in there too from long ago). So far it's more or less ok. Will see. I am heavily tempted to take the little tig back out now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: moe214
Hey Viktor, how is the aquarium adventure going? I was following the planet catfish thread, but haven't seen any updates since the storm, all ok?
 
Just a update. Got him a buddy yesterday. Also how much do they normally go for? I have 60 for the 2 I have and figured it had to be good price for this fish but not sure since this is the first time I have kept them. Also keeping them with 3 severums and brachyplatystoma rousseauxii. Good combo so far I see. Biggerthebetter sorry for your loss not what we wanna hear.

20161129_110314.jpg

20161129_110351.jpg
 
Nice! Now we'll learn how they get along with each other.

$30 each platynemum? I'd say that's unheard of. The cheapest I've ever seen them was $60 from snookn21. Where do you get them from? I wonder if I could try again, if the place still has them and ships.

As I feared, the gang in the "not so peaceful" 4500 gal did kill the smaller 8" tig overnight. The 10"-er seems ok still.

Hey, Adam, all is the same here, still tinkering. Will provide an update soon then.
 
Nice! Now we'll learn how they get along with each other.

$30 each platynemum? I'd say that's unheard of. The cheapest I've ever seen them was $60 from snookn21. Where do you get them from? I wonder if I could try again, if the place still has them and ships.

As I feared, the gang in the "not so peaceful" 4500 gal did kill the smaller 8" tig overnight. The 10"-er seems ok still.

Hey, Adam, all is the same here, still tinkering. Will provide an update soon then.
Actually 60 a piece. They hang together a lot so far from what I see. The rousseauxii stays to himself. What do you think did that to the tig? Kinda new I wasn't gonna be able to comm these with my tig or false. They have way to much attitude for these lol. Oh btw got them from local vendor here in ga.
 
Last edited:
Yea, we are brothers in bad luck. Mine has just met its demise too, two days ago. I'm a fish hoarder, not keeper, and this is the price.

I've had it since Mar 2016, when I got it from John Gerber's in Dayton Ohio at about 8" for $200. Spent the first months trying to get it to eat cut fish and pellets. It did. Had to rehome it about 3 times between different 240 gal tanks because tank mates bothered it - other brachies, wels, etc. So I thought I'd take a risk and place it in "peaceful community" 4500 gal a week ago. It was ~10". It lasted 3-4 days. Its tail got tattered but it had happened dozens of times before. Then one evening I've found front half of it stuck on the drain screen. Heartbroken. What's worse is that in this big recent reshuffling I have got two 240 gal out of ten empty and could have put it there and no one would bother it anymore but thought it could be better in a 4500 gal because it likes to swim. I've no idea who killed it. I've seen fish "come say hi" and some fleeting interest from a 16" VATF but really IDK who killed it and ate the hind half and whether it was even the same fish.

Slobber is a timid fish. Never bothers others but others bother it. It was not the smallest or the weakest fish in the 4500 gal but someone definitely had a tooth for it. I also placed an 8" tig in there too at the same time along with a 10" one (and there is a 14" one in there too from long ago). So far it's more or less ok. Will see. I am heavily tempted to take the little tig back out now.
sorry to hear, sucks. And the tig to.. always wondered how you had atf in a peaceful comm because they can be aggressive and have the capability and tools to do damage as you know
 
Actually 60 a piece. They hang together a lot so far from what I see. The rousseauxii stays to himself. What do you think did that to the tig? Kinda new I wasn't gonna be able to comm these with my tig or false. They have way to much attitude for these lol. Oh btw got them from local vendor here in ga.
$60 is a good price. Predatoryfins have 4" for $50 right now.

IDK who's done this. I think could be pbass.

sorry to hear, sucks. And the tig to.. always wondered how you had atf in a peaceful comm because they can be aggressive and have the capability and tools to do damage as you know

That's why I place it in quotation marks. It is only relatively peaceful - a fish has to have either attitude or size of at least 8" to survive. It is not textbook peaceful with two 16" VATF, 7 pbass three of which are 14", 6 pack of vulture catfish 12"-18", 14" flowerhorn, 12" umbee, 1' arapima, two 1' yellowcheeks, 1' Hemibagrus spilopterus, two 10" murray cods, and a hundred other fish. And two jerks - 10" banded leporinus.

I call the other 4500 gal "aggressive". The labels are for my purposes. Standard peaceful community has corydoras, hoplo, loaches, danios, angels, mollies, etc.
 
  • Like
Reactions: moe214
$60 is a good price. Predatoryfins have 4" for $50 right now.

IDK who's done this. I think could be pbass.



That's why I place it in quotation marks. It is only relatively peaceful - a fish has to have either attitude or size of at least 8" to survive. It is not textbook peaceful with two 16" VATF, 7 pbass three of which are 14", 6 pack of vulture catfish 12"-18", 14" flowerhorn, 12" umbee, 1' arapima, two 1' yellowcheeks, 1' Hemibagrus spilopterus, two 10" murray cods, and a hundred other fish. And two jerks - 10" banded leporinus.

I call the other 4500 gal "aggressive". The labels are for my purposes. Standard peaceful community has corydoras, hoplo, loaches, danios, angels, mollies, etc.
Ones smaller predators ones larger predators lol interested in what the spilopterus looks like
 
Spilopterus used to be called nemurus but let's try to keep this one about herman's slobbers. My bad.
 
  • Like
Reactions: moe214
MonsterFishKeepers.com