Any rules of thump for adding natural rocks?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Maximus146

Plecostomus
MFK Member
Oct 22, 2020
119
128
51
47
I have a 125L tank that I’m trying to do something realistic with being a good-sized tank so in addition to adding possible live plants, I’ve been looking around a small creek for some rocks. I would assume to let them soak in water for a few days before putting them in my tank but should I know about anything else? I’m trying to add depth and reality (ya know….like the Amazon….lol) and so I figured varying rock bed depths, driftwood and some rocks might look good.
Thanks,
Chris
 
Last edited:
I recommend boiling them for a few minutes each just to be safe. Make sure that you allow them to cool for a day at least before adding them to the tank.
 
In addition to cleaning them well (boiling sounds good), and depending on several factors (below), then you may have additional considerations-
1- Since you seem keen in "Amazon' biotope, then rocks should NOT be calcium carbonate containing. Thus, no limestone or any sedimentary or metamorphic stone that WILL raise the pH. They should be chemically inert, best igneous such as basaltic, granitic or quartzitic. No 'coral' rock, 'holley rock' or any of the sort.
2- Depending of where you live, you may be able to easily find igneous rocks, but in some locales (say, the Midwest where most of what you find is limestone) you will be out of luck and need to get them from somewhere else.
3- Best is not having sharp edges where fish can get scraped.

Good luck rock hinting!
 
Bigger rocks you will want to place directly on the bottom glass. This way the fish can't dig out the sand underneath and cause it to fall over.
You can also silicone rocks together so stacks can't fall over.
 
All good suggestions. I will just add that I have read...don't know if I trust it...that rocks are dangerous to boil as you run the apparent risk of the rock exploding with some force if it contains water or trapped pockets of air or some such. Like I said, I have no idea how valid this is. If I were worried about bringing in pathogens or other creepy-crawlies on "wild" rocks, I would just give them a bleach dip. Fast, easy, effective, and a simple rinse-off and drying period will ready them for your tank.

And, if you want to achieve a natural look, try to get all the rocks of the same type and roughly the same texture. A tank with all rounded, water-worn smooth rocks of various sizes, or all jagged, broken, angular and irregular pieces, will look more natural. Mixing all different types and shapes tends to look a bit hokey. In nature, almost all rocks are found laying down on their largest face. Balancing them on end, or stacking big ones on top of little ones to create caves, never looks "right". Don't try too hard to assemble or balance them; dumping them on the ground, and then transferring them to the tank laying the way they fell, usually works.

Congrats on deciding to find your own. I am continually amazed that people will pay the insane prices that LFS and pet shops charge...for rocks that look as though they broke off a meteorite from outer space. Expensive and unnatural; great combo. If your circumstances force you to buy rather than "hunt" your own, go to a landscaping supply place and pick through what they have. Again, all from the same pile or piles of similar types. You will outfit your tank for a tiny fraction of what they would cost at the aquarium store. The one I frequented when I lived in the city simply weighed the truck/car on the way in and again on the way out to determine the difference, and then charged by the pound at a super-cheap rate.

Good luck, show us some pics!
 
In addition to cleaning them well (boiling sounds good), and depending on several factors (below), then you may have additional considerations-
1- Since you seem keen in "Amazon' biotope, then rocks should NOT be calcium carbonate containing. Thus, no limestone or any sedimentary or metamorphic stone that WILL raise the pH. They should be chemically inert, best igneous such as basaltic, granitic or quartzitic. No 'coral' rock, 'holley rock' or any of the sort.
2- Depending of where you live, you may be able to easily find igneous rocks, but in some locales (say, the Midwest where most of what you find is limestone) you will be out of luck and need to get them from somewhere else.
3- Best is not having sharp edges where fish can get scraped.

Good luck rock hinting!
Great advice….thanks for the tips ??
 
All good suggestions. I will just add that I have read...don't know if I trust it...that rocks are dangerous to boil as you run the apparent risk of the rock exploding with some force if it contains water or trapped pockets of air or some such. Like I said, I have no idea how valid this is. If I were worried about bringing in pathogens or other creepy-crawlies on "wild" rocks, I would just give them a bleach dip. Fast, easy, effective, and a simple rinse-off and drying period will ready them for your tank.

And, if you want to achieve a natural look, try to get all the rocks of the same type and roughly the same texture. A tank with all rounded, water-worn smooth rocks of various sizes, or all jagged, broken, angular and irregular pieces, will look more natural. Mixing all different types and shapes tends to look a bit hokey. In nature, almost all rocks are found laying down on their largest face. Balancing them on end, or stacking big ones on top of little ones to create caves, never looks "right". Don't try too hard to assemble or balance them; dumping them on the ground, and then transferring them to the tank laying the way they fell, usually works.

Congrats on deciding to find your own. I am continually amazed that people will pay the insane prices that LFS and pet shops charge...for rocks that look as though they broke off a meteorite from outer space. Expensive and unnatural; great combo. If your circumstances force you to buy rather than "hunt" your own, go to a landscaping supply place and pick through what they have. Again, all from the same pile or piles of similar types. You will outfit your tank for a tiny fraction of what they would cost at the aquarium store. The one I frequented when I lived in the city simply weighed the truck/car on the way in and again on the way out to determine the difference, and then charged by the pound at a super-cheap rate.

Good luck, show us some pics!
Definitely agree with getting rocks if the same type and look to keep the look of the tank natural and uniform. Right now I have a few pieces of flagstone rocks under driftwood that have gotten some algae and darkened which I like
 
  • Like
Reactions: tlindsey
I recently rescaped my tank with rocks and sticks i got from the beach.
I just blasted them with the hose then left them soaking for a month, the sticks all grew a white film but I wiped them down then hosed them all off again.
4 weeks into the tank and no issues, personally i wouldnt boil the rocks but maybe a bleach dip if you are nworried. I think if they are dry when you collect them all water type bacteria would already be dead.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Maximus146
MonsterFishKeepers.com