Don't know how they'll do with the cichlids since I just go my first Africans this week but I have Java fern in 2 of my tanks. One is pretty heavily planted with hot5 lights and gets ferts and it does fine. Another is my fluval chi Betts tank that gets no ferts and for the first 2 months I forgot the tank had a light and it does really well in there. Basically if the cichlids don't shred them,they will live.