Anyone know anything about Carpintis?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
The carpintis (green texas) is a beautiful fish, glad you're thinking of getting one. :) It's possible for a syn and a carp to share a 75g, depending on the dimensions.

Though the main question is info on carps, so I'll talk about that.

Carps can be very aggressive or very placid, and sometimes seems to alternate between both. This is because a lot of people don't keep them properly.

Carps like to hide in reeds in nature, and feel most comfortable when there as places to hide in that's far from the prying eyes of things (you). Drift wood, caves, plants, stuff like that works.

They accept all sorts of food, though will seem to leave feeders alive. Don't be fooled, they are opportunistic and will eat guppies and stuff if one strays too close. They're just not active hunters. Of course you may find some individuals behave differently, but overall... yeah.

Carps come in a Super Green (Texas) form, which have amazing colors. Just absolutely beautiful. Most commonly are these collected from Escondido or Vontehillo. If you want to be classy, you can refer to them by their scientif names, 'Herichthys carpintis var. Escondido/Vontehillo'. :P

All carps have the ability to alternate their colors between blue and green at will, entirely up to them. In the Super Green Texas variety, the contrast will be very stark and will be just absolutely amazing.

When breeding, they will 'put on' a breeding dress, and you will see the back half of the carp go very black, the front half go pale bar the jaws, which will also go black. Google 'Carpintis breeding dress' and you will know what I'm talking about. Sometimes these appear during aggression, though apparently the black on the jaw won't appear in that case.

They've been said to go to 12 inches max, but the more common aquarium sizes are 8-10 inches.

They don't really need any sort of specific water parameters to live in. They're pretty much about as hardy as Convicts.

They are known to be prolific breeders, and is also said to be very, very, very in terms of mating choices - whilst some other CA cichlids will be more choosy, carps won't care if their mate is a festae or a red devil. Apparently.

Anyways, have fun keeping 'em! :)
 
What about a carpintis and a chocolate cichlid, or maybe a severum? I know the synspilum would be too big probably, but I do like the way the carpintis looks. Now that I know where to get one, I have to choose between a carpintis or a geophagus setup. I would rather have both, but I just don't have enough tanks for that. How long does it take for a carpintis to grow to a good sizeand good color? The geophagus I was considering previously take 2 years to develop full size and color. I am definitely leaning towards the carpintis, they are on my list of cichlids that I really want to try.
 
Both of the combinations would definitely work, Carp and choc or carp and severum. I'd suggest the choc.

I don't know the years, specifically, but Carps can show their colors from very young, assuming you get the SGT variety. 3 inches even. Do you mind PMing the link to the site? If they have pictures I want to see what sort of Carp they are.
 
I kind of like the idea of a chocolate cichlid, had one several years ago. It was very mild mannered, wouldn't fight anyone. Of course, each one has its own personality. It's worth the wait to see what they will look like and act like as they grow up. Maybe I'll try a pair of carps and see if I could spawn them, never had a breeding pair of anything. Could probably sell some to local stores since no one here carries them.
 
Both of the combinations would definitely work, Carp and choc or carp and severum. I'd suggest the choc.

I don't know the years, specifically, but Carps can show their colors from very young, assuming you get the SGT variety. 3 inches even. Do you mind PMing the link to the site? If they have pictures I want to see what sort of Carp they are.

I've never dealt with Chocolates or Severums, but I've heard they're very mild mannered. I don't know if I have an uncommon SGT or what, but he's been a glassbanger since 5" (now 6") and attacks my hand if I'm working in the tank and roughs up my male Cuban and that's in a 135gallon tank. I'm not sure how well that attitude will work out on a mellow fish...but maybe mines just a knucklehead and not the usual Carpintis


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app
 
These were my carpintus back in Feb this year @ 1"
236.jpg

the largest male today, 5"
046.jpg

Chocolates and severum would seem to me to be a bit timid to be housed with carpintus, and may be bullied, unless you acquired all together as fry and grew them up together.
 
jag14 - Yep, indeed they will all vary. XD A pair of carps might be a good idea, though spawning them may induce problems in and of itself, different than that of keeping different species of cichlids. Guess it depends on whether or not you want to deal with the drama of spawning or not. XD

MTBjake - Lol, yeah that sounds like an one of a kind. Carpintis are known to be mildly aggressive - they'll stand their ground and push others out of their territory, but never really going to the point of damaging badly and/or killing. XD Back when I first got my first one it couldn't decide to be super aggressive or super mellow, so it decided to alternate between the two. At certain points it's gone and hidden and scared of everything, other times its the absolute queen of the tank, pushing everything else away. It's now settled down and decided to be in between - i.e. the usual Carpintis mildly aggressive personality. They're weird fish, Carps are, but they're awesome.
 
MTBjake - Lol, yeah that sounds like an one of a kind. Carpintis are known to be mildly aggressive - they'll stand their ground and push others out of their territory, but never really going to the point of damaging badly and/or killing. XD Back when I first got my first one it couldn't decide to be super aggressive or super mellow, so it decided to alternate between the two. At certain points it's gone and hidden and scared of everything, other times its the absolute queen of the tank, pushing everything else away. It's now settled down and decided to be in between - i.e. the usual Carpintis mildly aggressive personality. They're weird fish, Carps are, but they're awesome.
Yeah I love mine. I had a Cyanoguttatum about 15 years ago that was a complete nut. Always attacking the glass--crazy. This is my first Carp. so I just assumed they were mentally the same as Cyanos :-)



Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app
 
Do they get friendly and recognize their owner? Seems like most of the big cichlids at least recognize who feeds them. I don't know about trying to pet one like an oscar, but maybe hand feeding? I like to spoil my fish as much as possible.
 
I'm glad this was right at the top of the forum! I just bought three 1" juvies yesterday from a local fish auction, for $3 :D Even at their small size, they have pretty pearls and nice shades of blue on their fins. I'm hoping to get a pair out of these guys and am glad to read that they can be housed with other fish!
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com