Apisto or Discus

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

TripleW

Jack Dempsey
MFK Member
May 5, 2012
632
24
33
45
Iowa
So recently I have been toying with the idea of trying my hand a breeding Apistogramma. I wanted to set up 4 tanks with a few different species and see what I could do with them. Today I stumble across a good deal on some 2 inch discus. I have always wanted to grow some out and see how I do as well.

Which would you pick? Which would be more rewarding in your eyes?
 
Discus will require more space and more work than Apistos to get them to adult size from 2". If you are committed to the water changes I'd say go for it, otherwise it's probably best to stick with Apistos.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TripleW
i recently got a pair of Aspisto and they are cool, I have them in a 50g so ill be adding a few more females in the coming weeks. the attitude is comparable to a convict I think,small fish syndrome.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TripleW
I agree on the tank space thing, you can do apistos in a smallish tank.

Otherwise... I successfully did them together, same tank, for a while. So it's not necessarily either or, unless budget or tank space (or preference) says so. At least for me, while I did enjoy the variety of apisto species, and some of them are quite attractive, there's just no real comparison. For me discus are just a more striking, more impressive fish, with a lot more presence. Discus can also be very interactive with you-- when they're happy and secure, that is.

I know there are plenty of apisto devotees out there, but for me I remember doing discus, the tanks were discus tanks, I think about doing discus again someday. The apistos were an interesting little fish, but like some of the other fish I kept with them they were simply a nice addition to my discus tanks.

On the other side of the ledger, apistos are relatively straightforward. There's not all the debate, or so much conflicting advice, over this, that, and everything else about keeping them, like there can be with discus. There's a lot of advice out there on discus keeping, that while I won't go so far as to say it's wrong, is either not the only way to do it or is simply not necessary in keeping them... or only becomes necessary with a particular approach to feeding and keeping them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TripleW
I'm on the opposite side of the coin from Neutrino. Discus do not appeal to me, while Apistogramma are one of my favorite genera. The neat thing about Apistogramma is that there is so much going on in such a small package. Their courting behavior is interesting, a mid sized tank can house multiple breeding females, and the females are great parents. I always enjoy seeing a Apistogramma female lead her fry around.

Just avoid the black water species of Apistogramma. Those species are arguably just as difficult, or more so than discus.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TripleW
I prefer discus for the same reasons as neutrino. I would base it on tank size and your home water parameters. If you're lucky and in an area that has netral water or softer out of your tap, captive discus will do fine and you can get them in wild colors like tefe, santarem, and alenquer. You can put a group of 6 of these and in a larger tank, a harem of apistogramma panduro, or cacautoides, or njisenni.

50 percent water changes once a week, live plants, and plenty of filtration and your tank will not need all the hassle that many who keep discus claim.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TripleW
I would say opposite's. I find them far more interesting then discus, they are smaller so you can keep more species, and the challenge and reward of breeding apisto's really makes it fun to keep them in my experience.
 
Discus at 2" will take you a minimum of 10-16 mo of daily care to get them to adult size of 4.5-6"+ and ready for breeding. If you have the time to commit to daily water changes and provide a high protein diet to achieve max growth then go for it! It will be rewarding once they breed and your raising the fry!
 
  • Like
Reactions: TripleW
MonsterFishKeepers.com