Aquascaping vs. Fish-Only: Where do you draw the line?

[henrycarter]

I’ve been seeing some incredible planted tanks lately, but sometimes I feel like the fish get lost in the greenery. On the other hand, a bare-bottom tank is so much easier to keep clean for larger species. How do you guys strike a balance between a beautiful aesthetic and a practical environment for your fish? Curious to hear your thoughts on form vs. function.

 

[A201]

Simply put, don't emphasize plants.

Construct a hardscape of rock & wood that affords the clear viewing you want, and still provides a beautiful, natural look.

I really don't like the unnatural look of bare bottom tanks. I tried that years ago with Discus. I quickly grew tired of the daily removal of detritus and fish crap.

 

[tiger15]

I don't need to strike a balance. I keep both plants and big cichlid in my aquascaped tanks, just select the right fish, plants and strategy to make it work. No bare bottom tank, just a thin layer of gravel to cover the bottom reflecting, most plants are epiphites, some potted, and all have tough texture to resist abuse.

 

[danotaylor]

Im the one who has to look at my tanks, so I really don’t care what others think of how I set up them up. Compliments about the scape are nice but don’t float my boat. In the same way criticism doesn’t sink it.

When I see a tank with bright pink & blue substrate I have zero urge to comment.

Simply put, each to his own