Are These Longnose?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
well, the one looks pretty good, but the other hardly has any spots.


I could probably drop it down to 75 but only until the aro gets big enough to go in there. at this point, it's looking like I'm going to pass.
 
pwmin;1725550; said:
I didn't mean to insult you or anything by saying "opinion". I know you wouldn't give any unfounded information as "fact".

I have no problem getting rid of the Texas (it was a rescue) and would get rid of the jag if it got aggressive at all, but I don't think I should drop the temp below 78. If it was a florida/spotted, I would probably be better off. I'm not set on getting this fish, so I won't if that is the consensus. Hopefully, they will go to a good home.

Florida / spotted would be a bit better for the types of fish you have than longnosed. If you run across these grab them.

On temp: Longnosed tend to do much better at temps 65 to 75. they feed better have a more regulated and steady growth and are less compromised physiologically in this range. A unheated tank is Ideal more for these reasons then behaviorally. No matter what they are skittish outside of a group and very prone to destroying themselves without taking the usual skittish gar precautions..
 
Polypterus;1726358; said:
Florida / spotted would be a bit better for the types of fish you have than longnosed. If you run across these grab them.

On temp: Longnosed tend to do much better at temps 65 to 75. they feed better have a more regulated and steady growth and are less compromised physiologically in this range. A unheated tank is Ideal more for these reasons then behaviorally. No matter what they are skittish outside of a group and very prone to destroying themselves without taking the usual skittish gar precautions..

it's almost safe to say that these gar along with the shortnose were not meant to be a fish for the home aquaria. there seem to be many cons and very few pros in keeping them...aside from the sheer beauty of the fish. i'm not saying people cant and havent kept them successfully, but in general they just dont seem to be the ideal aquarium gar. given the info stated above i myself may actually hold off on getting them again until i set up an individual tank for them (for life).
 
fair enough. thanks for everything. I'll hold off unless I can maybe find a FL/spotted

I am probably getting rid of the Tex, anyway.
 
pwmin;1726459; said:
fair enough. thanks for everything. I'll hold off unless I can maybe find a FL/spotted

I am probably getting rid of the Tex, anyway.

also be on the lookout for tropical gar. they are awesome and do great in aquaria...although they are much more rare than the florida/spotteds. just a thought.
 
demjor19;1726506; said:
also be on the lookout for tropical gar. they are awesome and do great in aquaria...although they are much more rare than the florida/spotteds. just a thought.

H2O (Mike) will be bringing some more in this spring so they should be available soon... I would highly suggest this fish as they really are the best of the Lepisosteids to keep in the standard community aquarium..
 
Polypterus;1729294; said:
H2O (Mike) will be bringing some more in this spring so they should be available soon... I would highly suggest this fish as they really are the best of the Lepisosteids to keep in the standard community aquarium..

even better than sp/fl? i thought they got more aggressive?
 
xander13;1729302; said:
even better than sp/fl? i thought they got more aggressive?

they seem much more stable than any florida/spotted i have worked with. truely an all around awesome fish!

they are more aggressive, but not too bad. you just need to watch what you put in with them.
 
demjor19;1729311; said:
they seem much more stable than any florida/spotted i have worked with. truely an all around awesome fish!

they are more aggressive, but not too bad. you just need to watch what you put in with them.

thanks fot the input!
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com