b-man;974914; said:
yeah, it'll be interesting to see how interstate/intrastate works out. thinking ahead, it would un-realistic to expect an end receiptant to import a fish at a time. not impossible, but really hard.......
i'm not sure how much of an issue WC fish would be. WC looks nothing like the fish we see in thru selective breeding (ie colors, shape, ...). so only a few people would prefer wild caught. plus the cites farms would be risking their cites status should they decide to risk it.
I agree. First, I don't think you could import one at a time from any farms in Asia. It's most likely going to be like it's done in Canada. Panda will sell 10 at a time I think. I've seen some farms with minimum orders as low as 2 though. Ideally, the importer would pay the import "tax" on each fish imported. Then each person buying one from the importer would also pay the "tax" to get a permit. Double taxation, I guess, but it's not technically a tax, and the point of the program is to help save the fish in the wild, not run a business.
The reason for each person paying the "tax" is that in order to "take" (which includes import and possess) you would need a permit. You couldn't import a fish without a permit, and you couldn't keep a fish without a permit, so both parties would need to pay for a permit.
There isn't anything else like this. You have to think of it as a donation to aid in conservation, not your typical tropical fish import operation. After all, these aren't your average tropical fish, and they ARE endangered in the wild. We shouldn't expect to be able to trade them like there is nothing wrong in the wild.
Personally, I agree that they should be taxed every time they change hands. it's feasible that one fish could generate thousands of dollars in conservation funds if it goes from importer to consumer, then from the original consumer to another consumer and so on. I actually think it should be like this throughout the world!
I know from a "profitability" standpoint all of this sounds rediculous, but again, you have to think of this as a conservation effort, not a tropical fish business.
Forgetting that we're talking about a rare species of fish that is very limited in geographic distribution is partially why they're endangered.