I have the 48-60" sat+ on three 125g tanks and I really like them, but I really doubt they would be enough light for a planted tank. I like how it lights up the center of the tank well, but leaves the edges a bit darker. It allows the fish a break from the light.
I have not tried the other brands you mentioned, but did try the marineland led lights for a short time. They were returned almost immediately because I felt they washed out the fish and tank. You could not control the color at all. I want a "realistic" daytime look, but at the same time I like the flexibility of the sat+ to include tints of specific colors.