Beani

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
My 8 beani did extremely well in my pond over the summer. They pretty much doubled their size in 4 months and fed actively. When I brought them in, the males were 7-8", the females about 5-6". I decided to spread them around into several tanks (a mistake ... ended up losing two). One pair looked like they were setting up to spawn, but then, became very reclusive and refused to eat. I presently have them in their own tanks, at about 72-74 F. They look good (a little pale but no sign of bloat ... yet). I've added some magnesium sulfate to their water and have just started a metronidazole treatment. Keeping my fingers crossed that they start eating again. This is my second round with them (the first, a couple of years ago).They were great up to around 3-4". Then I made the mistake of putting them in a large tank with other cichlids. They all bloated and died over the course of a few weeks. I believe (and as others have stated) that it was mainly from stress. I now keep the temperature low, feed sparingly with low protein/high spirulina food, and don't crowd them. I thought I had these latest ones "over the hump" regarding these sorts of problems but apparently not entirely. They are a challenge.

IMG_1025.JPG

IMG_1007.JPG

MVI_1051-001.jpg

MVI_1051-001.jpg

IMG_1025.JPG

IMG_1007.JPG
 
From what I understand the 2 location variants of beani are each from different river systems, it has been suggested that there may be a diet difference that predisposes a certain color. This may be due to the type, or amount of algae consumed.
Whether or not this will eventually lead to species separation only time will tell.
To me, beani are very much like haitiensus, in that if they cannot kill another cichlid that enters their realm (especially if the area is small), they are stressed into death themselves. This seems to be a trait held by those cichlids that are from an area where they are the lone cichlid in their habitat (ie haitiensus).
As Jim's did, my beani did well in the outdoor pond, but the pond was about 1500 gallons, and they seemed to cordon off an entire corner of maybe 200-300 gallons, where no other cichlids dare enter.

It was the area in the top right of the pic, and had an area of about 4ft X 4ft.
It was only 1ft-2ft in depth, but that allowed them to patrol the perimeter, keeping all others out.
 
The "white" beani I posted was collected by JoeFatFish 2 hours south of Baluarte is Rio San Pedro, Nayarit. The "green" beani was collected in rio Baluarte. I see vendors selling beani from Rio Panuco.
 
I've had success growing out Beani in a community setting and solo. It took about two years before I had to separate the Beani from the community tank. Right now, I'm growing out a male in its own tank with no heater and feed a low protein diet.


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app

I wish the white beani were more available. They are one of the most stunning fish out there!


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app
 
The "white" beani I posted was collected by JoeFatFish 2 hours south of Baluarte is Rio San Pedro, Nayarit. The "green" beani was collected in rio Baluarte. I see vendors selling beani from Rio Panuco.
Now I know and remeber the original white Beanis are from san Pedro. I remember this San Pedro Beani era now.

but this is the one Rio Panocio Beani I bought from Rapps as "white Beani". I got him feb 2010 then got rid of him shortly after. He wasnt white and did not look like he was heading that way either. But a very nice, elegant looking ,and extremely mean fish

IMAG1246.JPG

IMAG1120.JPG
 
My 8 beani did extremely well in my pond over the summer. They pretty much doubled their size in 4 months and fed actively. When I brought them in, the males were 7-8", the females about 5-6". I decided to spread them around into several tanks (a mistake ... ended up losing two). One pair looked like they were setting up to spawn, but then, became very reclusive and refused to eat. I presently have them in their own tanks, at about 72-74 F. They look good (a little pale but no sign of bloat ... yet). I've added some magnesium sulfate to their water and have just started a metronidazole treatment. Keeping my fingers crossed that they start eating again. This is my second round with them (the first, a couple of years ago).They were great up to around 3-4". Then I made the mistake of putting them in a large tank with other cichlids. They all bloated and died over the course of a few weeks. I believe (and as others have stated) that it was mainly from stress. I now keep the temperature low, feed sparingly with low protein/high spirulina food, and don't crowd them. I thought I had these latest ones "over the hump" regarding these sorts of problems but apparently not entirely. They are a challenge.

View attachment 962593

View attachment 962594

View attachment 962592

Great looking fish man I hope they dont bloat

Sent from my GT-I9300 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
 
If you keep them on the cool side, keep them away from other cichlids (and each other), and bloat shouldn't be a problem.
If you get youngsters, I have found having lots of plants that break sight lines and hiding places helps to keep them from killing each other.
I raised about 15 fry together for an almost entire summer that way, but when they were put together in a fairly (what I consider) sparse tank, they ended up dying rapidly.

The pic above is feeding time, but when not feeding they went their separate ways.
If they can see each other, they seem to intimidate the weaker of the 2 into death, much like haitiensus.
 
The "white" beani I posted was collected by JoeFatFish 2 hours south of Baluarte is Rio San Pedro, Nayarit. The "green" beani was collected in rio Baluarte. I see vendors selling beani from Rio Panuco.

I think rio panuco is a silver variant

Sent from my GT-I9300 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
 
Pics of my pair I bought from Joe with fry




Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app



well. I think White Beani is a market name.

They arent really white unless you catch it in a photo at an angle. Never Seen anything close to a white Beani except the one Lopaka had in a photo in the sun out of the water. I need to see more Beanis and learn
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com