Beginner ray

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

skillzdatkillz

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Mar 25, 2006
1,119
0
0
somwhere
Well Ive never kept a ray before but id like to try it. Is a hystirx ray good for a beginner? Could one live happily in a 18in wide tank (135) for a long time? People say rays need good water quality, my tank is running 5gals worth of bioballs and I do weekly 30-50% water changes, would that suffice? Im goin to add a canister in the near future, so that will help.

Thanks
 
Skillz did you find a ray without me?!? Hystrix are ok beginner rays, it just depends on what the condition of the ray is when you get it. (But I guess that goes for all rays). It definately does not get as large as Motoro and Leopoldi (probably the best beginner rays as per their ability to take a little more mistakes from the keeper) and I bet a small one would be ok in a 100 gallon if its 18 in wide for a while. But they do need space as they get bigger. The water changes you do will be fine as long as you dont stray from your regimine.
PS get me a pair too bro!
 
Hey man Im still lookin but Im tryin to get more info as I take part in my journey into ray keeping. Dont worry man I got u covered ;)
 
just because hystrix are cheap does not mean they are easy. A hystrix was the only ray I lost in a tank of 5. Don't know why....
 
Hystrix and Reticulata are some of the more common rays offered in the trade. As michael said, cheap doesn't necessarily mean easy. In fact, they seem to be more susceptible to water fluctuations than some of the other expensive rays. Price depends on supply and demand, but back to the thread subject :)...

I wouldn't lump hystrix in with the easiest of the rays for the beginner. Small motoros get my vote, along with humerosa and scobina. Just because the ray's adult size can be quite large doesn't mean that you can't keep it in a tank for a while.

As far as water issues go, keeping your parameters steady is the key, pH being the main thing. Large fluctuations will do just about any ray in. If your filter is properly cycled and rated for your current setup, it takes care of itself. Weekly water changes are sufficient, although with my setup, I can go 2-3 weeks between changes, but my filtration is overkill, haha. Let the test kits be your guide. Also routine substrate cleaning and filter cleaning is a must as dirty filters affect water quality as well.

Just as an example, one of my setups is a 125 gallon tank. The filtration for it includes a converted 29 gallon tank for a wet/dry with filter pads, crushed coral as a ph booster, 12 gallons of bio-balls, and lava rock. My overflow and pump are rated at 1200 gph. This handles the water quality issue, while 2 AquaClear 500's handle the mechanical issue. Make sure your tank is fully cycled and stable before adding rays.

skillzdatkillz: I am glad to hear that you are doing research, instead of jumping in with both feet :).
 
How fast do motoros grow? How long would one be in a 135. Im planning on getting one of those big rubbermaid tubs. What is a good ph for rays. My tap water is at like 7.8, is taht ok?
 
Well Ive never kept a ray before but id like to try it. Is a hystirx ray good for a beginner? Could one live happily in a 18in wide tank (135) for a long time? People say rays need good water quality, my tank is running 5gals worth of bioballs and I do weekly 30-50% water changes, would that suffice? Im goin to add a canister in the near future, so that will help.

Thanks
correct me if im wrong but dont you live in cali?
 
Cmon just trying to get some information here. I know they are illegal in cali but I dont plan on living in california forever. Thanks DeathCurl for giving me some info. Just want to get some of my questions answered
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com