BGK, Silver Aro, & Jardini "will it work???"

[Miguel]

The BGK is going to get killed. before that it will live hidden in stress.

It is true what The Trust is saying; but it is also true that only a very limited number of people have his type of tank. With the miscreants association he has in there, one jar more or less is tottally irrelevant.

Since you were talking about one jar and one Silver ( and not the Trust's convention of bandits ), IMO, you will have problems. 2 aro's alone is the way to have problems.

 

[JardiniBoy]

It could work, but there's a good chance that it won't. I have 2 knives (CK, RCK) living together peacefully with 3 aros (jar, greenie, SR) and a lot of other fish. If you do try it, be prepared for the worst ... spare tank(s) ... friends/LFSs that can take fish a short notice.

 

[The TRUST]

Yea i know !! I was more worried about that BGK.

yea but u didn't mention that the BGK is about 12" and the jardini is only about 6"

 

[andsco]

My Jar ate my BGK whole.

 

[killerfish]

no and no but mabye a jar with other big fish peacock bass would probly make good tankmates for a jar i think jars are like cichlids in small tanks with few fish they useually kill everything but when in large tanks with lots of other large fish it may work out

 

[rallysman]

Jed, your fish don't have enough room to fight. That doesn't count LOL

 

[skylar69]

it might work, my friends jar is as nice as can b, and i had my oscar with my bumble bee gobies untill he was 6", then he ate them

 

[ewurm]

Jed, your fish don't have enough room to fight. That doesn't count LOL

He's right Jed. Hows one Aro going to fight a dozen Pbass?

 

[adobongrabbit]

He's right Jed. Hows one Aro going to fight a dozen Pbass?

here is my silver, jar and bgk i have them for about 2 months ...i see no signs of agression...but i separate my 1 silver coz he's so mean u can see the last pix is the one that i separate i put him together with cichlids...my jar and my other silver have no worries now...

 

[Mishy]

I wouldnt risk it to be honest. Get seperate tanks if you want both fish.