So hopefully my inability to properly convey an idea through type written communication didn't throw you off. I meant to say as long as the polys mouths are smaller then the barbs you'll probably be ok. Geesh!My barbs are over 3.5 inches currently I would say. I know I have a huge fat one that is closer to 6.
Sorry should have mentioned I'm upgrading, my house is too small to try and keep a lot of the tanks I have. So I have to get rid of my 46 and 60 to make room. I know that I currently have some tetra and guppies, but I am confident that they will get eaten. And probably my harlequin rasbora.
Sounds like the barbs should be ok! Definite no go on rasboras, guppies and depends on what kind of tetra.
I did have some giant danios when I first started the 75 as the dels got bigger giant danios started to die. Usually kinda gruesome missing stomachs faces crushed. Never saw it happening and I have a ctenopoma that's pretty big too so may be that the cteno killed them and polys were just there right time right place since cteno couldn't swallow them. Not sure.