Wow don't know I missed this thread! Gorgeous fish everyone! Peter any chance you could post of list of all the SA cichlids you're keeping currently?
Just showing my guys... whom I think are 5 guys...
They are about 2 years old and two are about 4 inches, 1 is 3 inches and 2 are 2 inches. No spawning behavior.
I saw some wild caught adults in a LFS one time a few years back ... was shocked how big and thick they were, and their blue faces put discus to shame!!!
I shudder to think of how old they were to get that big though.
I tried these guys a few years back and although mine were nice they were very skidish. I stuck with them for about a year but wasn't wowed enough by them to continue so I traded them with a friend for some Urau. They are the slowest growing fish I have ever tried keeping next to my Gymnogeophagus.
Along the sames line and similar species, the 1.5-2" Guianacara I picked up at the GCCA classic this last Memorial Day are said to be over a year old.
I picked up seven 1.5" Guianacara a few months ago. While they are not very fast growers, they are not near as slow as the Biotodoma - my biggest Guianacara is bigger than my Biotodoma already, at least as long and twice as chunky.
Wow don't know I missed this thread! Gorgeous fish everyone! Peter any chance you could post of list of all the SA cichlids you're keeping currently?

Those are nice reference pics for sure ... though the ones I saw had less blue in their fins and much more on their faces. They had just come in though, so weren't settled in yet. Plus were over black gravel so were dark and unsettled so the blue in the fins just might not have been showing up. I love the blue in the fins of those pics though.
Nice cupidos. I never could get pics of mine, they were in a planted tank and constantly hiding.
Funny, mine are pretty front and center. And they LOOOOVVVEEE their pellets. I'm interested in the male female thing. I had read a while back... that most wild caught are males because the females are lower in the water column and are rarely caught when so many males are to be had. I would love to see a picture of a proven female if anyone has one.
And yes, these fish are meant to test your patience... the first year I thought they were completely uninteresting. But I very much like them now.
Supposedly cupido are very easy to sex but it's impossible to find females. According to Weidner, the males have solid blue lines under the eye while the females have blue dots or dashes. A lot of people say this is incorrect because all the fish they've seen in the hobby have lines, but maybe that explains why no one is spawning them.![]()