Black ghost knife with oscar?

[hasu12]

Can i keep an oscar with my ghost knife ??

Or any recommendations? Its new fish time

 

[kdrun76]

How big is the tank?

 

[Gobrian44]

i've done it lol...no problems at all

 

[hasu12]

good stuff , what kind of oscar did ya go for dude? were they similar sizes when you stuck them in together?

 

[benzjamin13]

Depends on the temperament of the Oscar. Some hare really aggressive and there are some that are pretty docile. Most would advise against it, but I've seen it work. On another note...if you have an establish tank with an Oscar being the resident, I would definitely not try it. They are very territorial and it most likely will not work.

 

[gregg]

i think u would need to grow out the black knife 1st i had an oscar which grew close to 10 inches in less then a year rip.... dam filter went out when i was gone the ghost knife grows slooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

 

[Hoyo12]

Depends on the temperament of the Oscar. Some hare really aggressive and there are some that are pretty docile. Most would advise against it, but I've seen it work. On another note...if you have an establish tank with an Oscar being the resident, I would definitely not try it. They are very territorial and it most likely will not work.

x2
Worked for me. 13" Oscar 7" BGK

 

[dbcb314]

I had a friend that did it with no problem

 

[clarius catfish]

Depend how big your tank is and what your Oscars temperament is like but they should be fine.

 

[flipstylex]

it will work, just make sure that the oscar cant fit the ghostknife in its mouth