I also have better luck using the "night shot" and "portrait" settings on my point and shoot cam. I have no patience for setting up my SLR, so I just take a barrage of pics and see what comes out, haha.
I got the bosmani's at Uncle Bill's for 9.99. It's the best LFS I know of that's in Indy but I need to grab the yellow pages and start doing some more exploring. I know the bosmani's are going into the 55 soon but right now there is not a problem. They all get along real well.
There is a place on S. Keystone that is okay. Most places around here seem to be over priced and don't really seem to carry odd things. I can find somethings at the Uncle Bill's on 38th sometimes. The places up in Marion and Muncie seem to have a better selection.