that was a female bowfin that you caught...the ones with the eye spot are males the females don't get that spot...they are fun to catch and have a nice set of teeth...
yup good ole bowfin. Call em Grennel round here. Or Cotton Eyed Joes. Thats super slang right there. Its because you have to fillet em within so many hours or the meat just turns to a cotton like texture and is uneditable . Just in case yall wanted a history lesson. First time I caught one didnt know what it was, tried to lip it!