Box of Americans from Don Conkels (with pics)

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Status
Not open for further replies.
actually, assuming they're all pure (big assumption) once they reach maturity there shouldn't be too much difficulty distinguishing them apart. The 2 biggest threats would be the bifasciatus/synspilus and the zonatus/hartwegi but even these, again assuming they're pure, should be fairly easily discernible.

I've kept both pure synspilus and bifasciatus from rapps and would be able to easily tell them apart....from the 2 that I kept. of course there will be differences from fish from different locales but still...generally speaking bifasc will have a black lateral line running the length of the fish whereas the synspilus will have one only covering the last approx. 1/3 of the body length. zonatus should have a solid black lateral line whereas hartwegi should not be fully solid and have vertical bars that come and go as well (though female zonatus also show this trait so that'll make it trickier). Though the face should give it away more as hartwegi should have red spotting on the face and the zonatus generally won't.

and actually at least half that problem should be cleared up as the DOA appears to be either the hartwegi or synspilum (i'd lean towards the syns. from the pic...was the bag it came in not labelled?)

very nice stocklist and can't wait to see them all as they grow....definitely keep us updated on their progress.

just my $0.02 :)
 
***update...yeah I kinda forgot about the regani and rainbow regani...these could prove very difficult since no one apparently has seen a rainbow regani. lol so yeah, identifying between these 2 may not be possible if they're in the same tank and weren't differentiated when they were shipped.
 
Mad About Cichlids;3599360; said:
So he didn't bag the following separately?

Vieja regani
Vieja rainbow regani

No, same bag. He was originally planning to use two boxes and bag most seperate but because of shipping issues he made some consesions to get them all in 1 box so I did not pay more for shipping than the fish.

Jason_S;3599608; said:
...generally speaking bifasc will have a black lateral line running the length of the fish whereas the synspilus will have one only covering the last approx. 1/3 of the body length. zonatus should have a solid black lateral line whereas hartwegi should not be fully solid and have vertical bars that come and go as well (though female zonatus also show this trait so that'll make it trickier). Though the face should give it away more as hartwegi should have red spotting on the face and the zonatus generally won't.

Thanks for the tips on figuring out who is who.
 
Nice collection you got there thats a good deal can't wait to see pics of them as they grow :D
 
Here is a pic the Don sent me of an adult Rainbow Regani.

Vieja_rainbow_regani.jpg
 
:jaw: gorgeous fish man good luck with all of them and you should do growth thread on the reganis and as they get older maybe wel be able to tell which is which:drool:
 
Open Water Predator;3605777; said:
Just curious, why is that a big assumption? Are you taking a shot at Don or what?

I agree, why do you think that Don Conkels fish arent pure? My LFS only deals with Don and he actually sends him his known hybrids because he hates them that much. Anytime your dealing with large scale fish breeding and collection your bound to get some hybrids, but I have only seen beautiful fish from Don and have loved everyone.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
MonsterFishKeepers.com