you guys are awesome, thats what I thought but the yellows around here are like that light olive yellow, so it was hard for me to believe I got one that dark in color, thanks all for the ID, thats why this site is awesome 


Our pleasure.
Fish usually don't look the same in captivity as they do in the wild. All differs. Water composition, food, space, temp, lighting, hiding facilities, stress level, sun light cycle, etc.
I agree completely, but now that I know Marty is a yellow I can tell you there is a HUGE difference in coloration from the lake yellows and the creek yellows that I catch. Marty is from Lake Arthur (PA aquarists will know Moraine State Park haha) then right down the road not 5 miles I catch yellows that are actually yellow or light light olive green. It has to be the difference in environment around here.
Rob,why don't you fix the thread title?
Yeah the yellows around us are fairly light colored. I caught my biggest yellow not to far south of lake Arthur and he darkened up real nice once in my tank.