Silversurfer - thanks for the kind offer of help. I do know exactly what the "real" calico's look like - their dad looks like your pic (except that mine are reg fin). Mom looks like that too (if mom is the calico and not the albino - see page 1 for more on this). I also know very well how to ship. Most of my shipments of ANY kind of fish take minimum of 3 days up to a max of 6 days (only once so far) - but in each case, all are fine. I have had a few fatalities over the course of my shipping "career", but out of well over 200 fish shipped, less than 15 have died - and none of them plecos (only cichlids). I "could" give live arrival guarantee, but "industry standards" call for live arrival only for express mail. I can make exceptions based on the number of fish ordered, where they're going, etc...
Now about my little plecos - no, I'm not offended (baffled by their genetics, but not offended). As the original post states, dad is a nice looking calico, and mom may be calico or albino - so I'm baffled as to why they don't look like either parent. However they do have some good calico genes, and if paired up with some "better looking calicos", should throw off some nice looking calico babies (at least that's my understanding of the genes).
So if they were indeed browns (instead of just looking like they are), then they would be cheaper. But since they are calicos (albeit throwbacks in the way they look), they are worth the $4 asked for them. I've had no trouble on other forums finding folks who want them. Not everyone is a breeder - most folks are like I was when I started - just wanting some AWESOME algae eaters that are cute, efficient, and inexpensive. If breeding happens, that's fine with them, but not their main goal.
I really appreciate the offer for help though. It was a generous offer and not taken lightly. So folks if you just want some cute algae eaters that have good genes even though they don't look like a "pedigreed" calico - these are the guys for you. Kind of reminds me of the kids of drop dead gorgeous couples who turn out to be "less than beautiful" - they still got great genes and their kids will probably be beautiful
