Can I mix these species of turtles and fish together?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thanks guys for the responses me and my cousin will probably go with for tankmates for the turtles are a black wolf fish curupira, golden dorado, black wyckii catfish/asian red tail catfish wyckioides, west african lungfish, two toed amphiuma or three toed version, and possibaly a pom pom/reticulated knifefish if it can handle itself well with the other aggressive fish and turtles and For the turtles a slider of some kind, a painted turtle of some kind, a west african mud turtle, a siebenrocki snake necked turtle, murray river turtle, and possibly a florida soft shell turtle.
 
Actually I think a brycon cephalus or red tail brycon would be better than a golden dorado which do you guys think would be better for the aquarium.
 
Last edited:
Personally I think you needs to do some research on all species you listed. Some species you listed are too aggressive/or too fragile. Stick with cheap goldfish or convict cichlids.
 
Which species are to fragile?
Clearly you didn't research on all species....
I personally won't mix amphiumas with anything. Asian RTC will kill everything. And I won't house softshell turtles with other turtles because of their aggressive nature.

Stick with cheap goldfish and convicts.
 
MN_Rebel MN_Rebel This dude never learn nor taking advises, you will see him make another thread with different title (or similar) and using different approach to ask exact same question over and over, search all his previous posts and you would understand.
 
Wow I didn't know asian redtail catfish could kill turtles would a vulture catfish be better because I don't want anything to go wrong?
 
Wow I didn't know asian redtail catfish could kill turtles would a vulture catfish be better because I don't want anything to go wrong?
that would be my last time to offer any advice to you because obviously you didn't do any homework at all.
 
Thanks guys for the responses me and my cousin will probably go with for tankmates for the turtles are a black wolf fish curupira, golden dorado, black wyckii catfish/asian red tail catfish wyckioides, west african lungfish, two toed amphiuma or three toed version, and possibaly a pom pom/reticulated knifefish if it can handle itself well with the other aggressive fish and turtles and For the turtles a slider of some kind, a painted turtle of some kind, a west african mud turtle, a siebenrocki snake necked turtle, murray river turtle, and possibly a florida soft shell turtle.


What happened here? Did someone cut up an encyclopedia of nature and pull out a bunch of random animal names? Just because they can be found in the same book in no way means they can be housed together.
Do us all a favor (counting yourself). Do a basic search on every animal in your list (even if it's just Wiki) and pare your list down to what can actually live together outside of Oz. Then, return and ask specific questions that don't rely on everyone else doing your basic research.

This nightmare is closed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
MonsterFishKeepers.com