can jack dempsey live with jaguar??

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
they should be fine. jd definately stands up to the jag in my tank
 
thanks for the responses guys! so far the jack dempsey and jag are getting along ok. they just stare each other down but dont do anything more.
 
"can Jack dempsey live with Jag?"

Answer: Only if Jag wants Jack Dempsey to live.
 
Maduro;4019901; said:
"can Jack dempsey live with Jag?"

Answer: Only if Jag wants Jack Dempsey to live.

true, the jag will eventually get a lot bigger than the jd and they grow at a much faster rate. its a hit and miss really, mine are doing ok now other than a few scraps occassionally, and you say yours are getting on...for now, but maybe in a years time things will be very different, in both our tanks. how big are they both now? mine are roughly 3 or 4"
 
My 6" male Jack will not tolerate any tankmates. I have tried him with an equal sized Texas, a 14" Oscar, and a 10" Pleco...all were almost killed within 24 hours. He is destined to be alone.

It all depends on the fish, your always rolling the dice when you mix cichlids in the same tank.
 
species compatibility is just a guideline if the jd acts big he will be fine. the major issue with fish this different is once the "little guy" backs down the bigger fish knows he owns. fish dont have health clubs and mirrors so most base aggression and dominance on reactions of the other fish, convicts that could be eaten my some tankmates coexist because they rarely back down.

Posted on mobile.monsterfishkeepers.com
 
  • Like
Reactions: pdxmonkeyboy
wats the demensions of your tank?
i only have a 100gal but mines 6'x18"x18" an i got lucky
my jag turned out to b female an paired up with my
jd. but they also grew up together with a couple of
other cichlids but they always were the two fighting
and had the biggest growth rate, jd faster then jag also
bred together craziest parents
 
I
Don't get too technical,the two are very compatible as long as you start them off reasonably young...
Don't get too technical,the two are very compatible as long as you start them off reasonably young...

I agree 100%. Im raising 2jags with green terror and a Jd andtheyg
Don't get too technical,the two are very compatible as long as you start them off reasonably young...


Agree 100%.currently im raising 2 jags with Jd and a green terror and they are going perfectly well together. They have been put together since they were 3 cm and no problems till now.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com