Catfish for a central american tank?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
I like Magnus_Bane Magnus_Bane idea of the channel cat for this tank. With a jag in there, all bets are off as to if the cat will be tolerated/left alive, so might as well make it a large, tough, less expensive fish like a channel cat.
 
In northern Central America the common catfish found are Rhamdia which are not often imported, these act and look very much like N American bullheads.
Eden2
Channel cats are similar but unless your tank is 1000 gallons, they will out grow it.
Here in southern Central America the Arius catfish are more numerous.
They are quite active compared to Rhamdia, and especially as young, in constant almost manic motion.
Many are brackish, and oceanic and also get too large. The brackish type that inhabit river deltas, are considered good eating.
Fishermen clean them at sea, but the heads often wash back to shore.


Catfish and cichlids have a sketchy relationship at best, preying on each others eggs and fry, often found together, are really arch enemies.
In nature they keep each others populations in check.
Some people don't think of Pleco's in the traditional sense as catfish.....
There are Central American Pleco's and Farlowella ( stick) catfish
The pleco below was caught with my cichlids in the San Martin area of Panama,
8BA15FE3-0075-40BF-870A-5972228782F5_1_201_a.jpeg
it has doubled in size from about 3" when 1st caught, to almost 6" within a year (1st day is the net photo, net is 4")319B3BAA-3B7E-4811-A56E-C42CC96B9CC2_1_201_a.jpeg
F32FC6B1-6B90-40C0-9ADB-AA5C1FA2E790_1_201_a.jpeg
it is a fair algae eater, but is also an opportunistic carnivore.

BCDA6F2E-9657-4A2D-A48A-FAA516642B43_1_201_a.jpeg
 
Thanks for the extra info duanes duanes . Whats the pleco in your photo? Would you say a titan pleco L418 would work out good in this tank? I have a common pleco in another tank. If I went with a pleco I would want something other than a common pleco. What are some you guys would recommend?
 
In the field guide I use "Peces de las Agues continentals de Costa Rica" published in 2002, (probably out of date as far as scientific names) go it is listed as Hypostomus panamensis.
F4A4483D-45E4-421B-8AA1-C1EA48809B03_1_201_a.jpeg
There is also a listing for another armored cat, Rineloricaria uracantha as endemic to the area.
Panamanians call them both Chupa pierdras, (Stone suckers)
Some of my other favorite bottom dwellers, that are common here in Central America have been the Gobies

Awaous transedeanus below also considered a stone sucker
DE79DC24-9B67-4072-821A-44AE6C393AB7_1_201_a.jpeg
and Eleotris picta
A8FD15E2-8C45-4905-9E96-4BEDE74FAB47_1_201_a.jpeg
D0F43E8D-CD23-44BB-A180-87B97409A1CA_1_201_a.jpeg
 
Probably going to keep him in by himself except for feeder fish I raise.
 
In a 300 gallon tank you have many more options than most average aquarists.
Managuese share waters with many similar size species, and there are plenty of others commonly available and endemic to the great lakes of Nicaragua, and other places in CA where managuense are common, and would be geographically correct (if that is your aim).
There are even Tetras that are common, and large (and fast enough) that could be used in the size tank (because of the escape room) as a shoal in that size tank.
Astyanax tetras get quite large and are almost the most common fish I see (beside mollies)when snorkeling.
Im using Roeboides tetras as shoaling type in my mostly cichlid Panamanian tank, these are about 4" at the moment.
5612DD39-0E2A-4E07-A154-FFD2B4BB8984_1_201_a.jpeg
Astyanax in the video below, although these are small (because I was hugging the shoreline) I have seen lots of 6+" specimens.
Aktun Ha
Note the Parachromis at about 1 minute +.
Beside the sleeper goby I have, Dormitor gobies are very common in the fresh waters of Central America, get large enough, and can hold their own.
My sleeper has gone from a size of @ 6" when it was fist caught in June, to almost 10" today.
3347450C-83BB-4410-9818-4C01FDC58359_1_201_a.jpeg
 
I was going to suggest some dithers as well but if you're feeding live fish I don't know if that's a good idea. Not Central American but a group of Tinfoils in a big tank are always impressive imo.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LDPatton
duanes duanes thanks again for all the info. I was thinking about having the jag with fish that live with and around them. I want to set it up to look natural and as close to what they live in but I never get any good videos when I try to search. I will watch that video to get a better idea for my tank. Very helpful info thanks again.
 
S Shark75 I dont know if it matters with a fish like a jag if you feed them live food or not. I just assumed if I have achooling fish from jags natural habitat they are gonna eat some. I wonder if my tanks large enough for the fish to reproduce enough to not have to buy more to replace the ones that do become prey.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com