Its two fish, 1st & 3rd are the same fish, middle one is another one.
I sent the photos to the Michigan DNR a fue years ago, and they thought they might be Grass Pickerel. But they told me to keep fishing and send them a photo of a big one if I could get it. A 5 pounder can't be a Grass Pickerel is what he told me, so he must have had some dout too. Unfortunitly I no longer have acksess to the Bog, its on private property and the people I knew sold.
I know Chain Pickerel are not Native, but in the past people stocked fish willy-nilly all over Chain Pickerel included. My Grandfather caught a Chain Pickerel out of the Kankakee River in Indiana back in 1953, it was 7 lbs, 14 oz. So concievibly they could be in Michigan. But without ceatching a big one we will have to assume its a color variation of Grass Pickerel.
Before these, I've only seen Grass Pickerel that had bars, or were clear, never with chain like markings. I've caught tons of them in my life, mostly in Indiana, but at least 20 or so out of Great Bear Lake, MI which is only 10 miles from this bog. None looked anything like these two.
Mike