Cichlid Id

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Carter020108

Polypterus
MFK Member
Dec 10, 2018
621
325
87
Sold to me as a friedrichstalhi but not sure it’s hard yo get a good picture but what do you guys think and do you know the gender1A58D850-BB64-4459-B777-13F08EA711CF.jpeg904F6C57-58F2-4380-A8CE-C5C6B2153703.jpeg6BA2494E-BB54-42B8-8B3F-8B00752A0910.jpegCF06A3D5-0731-40E3-A16B-D70A8CFB6E70.jpeg
 
Parachromis? Edit: oh it looks like you’re already aware it’s a para, just wondering what type. Unfortunately I am not sure.
 
On almost any adult Parachromis, (except dovii) a myriad of small spots (like the ones below) on the gill plate usually indicate a male. kind of visible in your first couple pics.
But if young this may change.
1653649301240.png
Mature 10=" male motaguense above.
Can't tell how large yours is, but it appears to be young, and when young almost all Parachromis look alike.
To get a better idea, clean the water spots off the outside glass, and if possible get a better, manual focusing camera.
Looks like you used a phone cam, which usually does not allow detail from the kind focus needed shooting thru glass.
And with all the random crossing done these days, "unless" you got it from a reliable source (meaning not a LFS that doesn't demand lineage info from local breeders) you may never know.
 
Does look like either a freddy, multi, mota. Like duanes said it's hard to tell the young ones apart, if teh vendor told you Freddy that's what I'd go with for now until it's large, then will be easy to tell.
 
The real question is it a P. friedrichstahlii based on outdated species identification or the current species identification.
 
Ag
The real question is it a P. friedrichstahlii based on outdated species identification or the current species identification.
Agree,
if its ancestors were imported from southern Mexico, Honduras, or another place in northern Central America. It would be P. friedrichstahlii.
But if its ancestors were imported from Panama, it would be P multifasciatus (formerly Loisellii).
Below photo are juvies of P sp "La Ceiba" from Hondurus

1653749560904.png
And below a video I took near Tulum in Cenote Aktun Ha, of P friedrichstahlii . At @ 1 minute, what appears to be a female appears, and then thoughout are a few juvies.
The other more prevalent cichlid species are introduced and feral Tilapines.
Aktun Ha
 
I guess we’ll only know as it gets bigger I got it off of eBay with no picture of parents so who knows
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com