compatible?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Your right trimac and the whole amphilophus family are beasts up until 7 inches after they sexually matured then they calm down and become more managable cichs but just doubt he gets that phycho one out of 50 there man but within reason,of life as fish, im talking as there bought at same time 1.5 to 2.5 inch .Better luck with the introduction, n black belt larger of the 2. But trimacs are cool but do wild out when and around sexual maturity and a little after to me good fish,but of course their are always factors,and more important the keeper and the fish,goodluck all ,thank for fish talk good or bad loved it,,,,for real

Not to criticize, but I think you have this backwards. They tend to get more aggressive after sexually mature. Trimac is already one of the most aggressive fish you can get & add it in a confined space is going to bring out the worst. The only way I've found to "lessen" aggression with the nastier amphilophus (& parachromis) species is to give them plenty of space. Black belts are pretty bold, but it isn't going to come out on top in a dispute with a big male trimac.
 
Biggers always better but just 2 fish in any tank needs something else to focus on unless paired or their mild. But those not that aggresive , its not like a grammode and a red tiger or a haitensis in there , thats relentless aggression ,it wont stop,, with just 2 they would need other focus, but could work 75, but yeah bigger the better , depend on the keeper too , me myself love to overcrowd but big tanks n overfiltrate too many spectators wow it . Started wit red snakeheads pikes and gars in early 90s .Liked the death fish, in 55 to 90 gal, young trial in error . First cichlid a strigatta pike he lived with a black rhom pirranah for a year plus it worked then sold both but in a 90 gal, not responsible on my end but worked ,now every where u read on net say it wont work, but in reality it did, but my fish i was the keeper they loved precooked shrimp earthworms and low ph easy pike 12 inch blk rhom 8 . Bigger is better , all fish have different character traits but 8 out of 10 he should see long life in those two.

2 fish, 3 fish or 10 fish a 4' tank isn't going to cut it unless it's a temporary situation. I think you underestimate the aggression of the 2 species in question. All my Vieja species are punks to some extent. And Trimacs are notoriously worse.

And adding a pleco will just add to the load so by trying to divert focus you're in effect kind of starting another problem. Plecos are crap factories. Danios or sds make better targets than plecos in the long run.

To the original question ..... Yes they can. Will they?

Maybe...maybe not.


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app
 
Sometimes you never know, but for me, I'd be a bit concerned about that trimac. I have seen people have them in community settings and/or with other fish, but it's rare. That fish is usually kept as a wet pet for a reason... they are known to get pretty nasty. Good luck!

-Rich
 
My trima. Male is about 10 in housed in a 125 gal with 5 silver dollars and a pleco. He recently killed a female red Texas he was paired with. I want to try pairing him again with a 10 in black belt or a 9 in midevil. The black belt I can get for $15 so I was wondering if they would breed. Thanks for the replies
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com