Black aro will do well in your tank. You may need to grow it out a bit first depending on the size of your cichlids. It is hard to say if the aro will eat smaller fish or not. I have two 27" black aros, they pretty much will leave most any smaller fish alone, ranging from serpae and black skirt tetras to silver dollars, angelfish and clown loaches. However if I put gialt danios in the tank, they will hunt them down rather quickly, so ya just won't know until ya try.