Pitt seems to be high on prices. imo I'm not sure where they get their fish from. The store in meadville used to be good, one I liked fish bowl I think is closed. I didn't care for the other one, buzzes or robs are way better man. Cleveland is good for getting fish on the cheap, if you sign up for RMS or John's aquarium online news letter you get coupons all the time. Somethingfishy is out there too. Buffalo is better for the harder to find species, ones that either get huge or would cost over $30 normally. Some cool stuff in the $30-$100+ range. That is about all I know outside of erie. There are a couple fish shops similar to buzzes in new york under an hour. One over by dunkirk that gets some nice stuff in, one over by lakewood. Buffalo is the best city I think for fish stores, Ive been to cinci, pitt, cleveland, akron, erie. Just visiting friends and googled what was in the area and checked out what was there. The stores in buffalo are rather far..north of buffalo up by niagara falls but pretty awesome.
Not worth the gas imo, so I usually see what rob has on the list, or just order online. I do like to go to buffalo once a year just to see the fish like the tarpon ariapima and tiger fish tigs and lacerade. Pretty impressive stores and stock.