Disaster Leads to Change...

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

rich_one

Plecostomus
MFK Member
Jan 6, 2011
1,141
4
53
Southern Maryland
Honestly, there is a part of this that still hurts, so forgive me for now if I don't get into the details of the disaster. Something happened, right now it is a total mystery, and I have lost prized fish because of it. That's the short, short version, and for the purposes of this thread, all that is really relevant at this point.

As the dust clears, I find myself in a position of having to make some decisions. As always, input from my peers here tends to prove to be invaluable. So... a few things:

1. I have a 75 gallon setup I purchased from a guy as a saltwater setup, probably 2 or 3 months ago. For many reasons, I have never actually set it up, oddly enough. Now, I am reconsidering setting up as a saltwater tank. I think I may set it up as a freshwater tank, and move my male lyonsi to this tank, and attempt to find him a female that he likes and won't try to kill. Assuming I move forward with this plan, is there anything special I have to do to a tank that was once setup as a saltwater tank, from a cleaning perspective to make sure no nasties or contaminants transfer to the freshwater environment (I imagine anything that could live in saltwater would probably be killed in freshwater... but you never know)? The tank has been dry since I've owned it the last two or three months, so if anything was ever alive in it, it's probably long dead now anyway. But safe beats sorry, right? I was just gonna wipe it down with vinegar, and flush it with clean water, basically.

2. Next, I am thinking of breaking down my 125 gallon CA tank, and rehoming my oscar, and maybe backing out of the "monster" cichlids for awhile. Next month, I am acquiring a pair of cutteri and a pair of geophagus steindachneri. I am thinking of rebuilding this tank around those. I may also move my severum into this setup, though I'm still deciding on that one. Assuming I go with this plan, I'm soliciting some suggestions on tankmates. I'd love to get one more cichlid pair that could coexist with the cutteri in this tank. I have many options as far as breaking up sight lines and creating territories. Also in this tank is a BN pleco, and a couple of bumble bee cats that I may or may not rehome... undecided on that as I type this.

As always, you guys (and gals) input is valued and appreciated!

-Rich
 
not sure what to say....

I know, man... it's really messed up. But I am just accepting that sometimes these things happen, and instead of dwelling on it, I am going to just embrace the excitement that comes with change. It's better than dwelling on the negative, anyway. If I do that, it's just too depressing. So... you could always make some suggestions for maybe a good pair of something that could coexist in the 125 with the cutteri and geos! :D

-Rich
 
Sorry to hear about your losses Rich. It happens to the best of us.

As for your questions, I don't think there is much you need to do to the 75 besides a good cleaning. My 180 was a salt set up before I got it. All I did was rinse it out and go forward. Any salt residue will quickly be dissapated with water changes.

With the cutteri and stienies in the 125, I would go with a single of a larger, mid tempered cichlid like a JD or carpintis. Stienies are pretty tough for a geo, and the cutteri can get aggressive when breeding.
 
So sorry, Rich. At least you found a positive way to deal with a bad situation. Maybe a pair of Rainbow Cichlids would work with the other pairs in the 125. They are not really aggressive but will defend their fry. A large school of Buenos Aires Tetras would look nice too. Let me know if I can help you out in any way.
 
Thanks, Gruff. I have a male rainbow right now in my 33 gallon, and am getting a female for him very soon, at my January club meeting. I have them in with some tiger bards on their own!

I appreciate the sentiment, man. I am still somewhat in shock, but the only thing I can think of to do to deal is just stay focused on what's next, and go from there.

-Rich
 
How about getting a small Midas around 2" and growing it out with the others. There has been some success with Midas in community tanks. I always like the look of at least one large cichlid in a tank and what better then having a wet pet. He would have plenty of room in the 125.
 
How about getting a small Midas around 2" and growing it out with the others. There has been some success with Midas in community tanks. I always like the look of at least one large cichlid in a tank and what better then having a wet pet. He would have plenty of room in the 125.
This is something I am actually giving some serious thought too. I have recently become rather enamored with midas cichlids, especially the creamsicle varieties, if I could find one!

Also, what do you guys think of cubans? Are they too aggressive for this, or might they be tempered similarly like JDs? I have never kept them, but another fish that has sort of gotten my attention lately. There's a guy near me selling a pair.

-Rich
 
Hey sorry about the loss...

As for the cubans mines are quite nasty so they will need to be kept with aggressive tankmates. The cutteri will probably do fine with them as I have read they can be nasty but the geos I am unsure they will be able to hang with the cubans.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com