Effects of feeding too much on tank water quality

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
I also have to a degree begun to figure that stuffed fish may not be any more healthy over long terms that obese dogs or cats.


From another recent discussion. I first posted about this shortly after this paper became public in 2004. In the early days of MFK many people believed in "power" feeding their fish for quick gains in growth. Myself and a few others attempted to explain how slower, more even growth, was better for the long term health of the fish.




An Evaluation of Two Commercially Prepared Feeds on Growth Performance and Liver Condition of Juvenile African Cichlids Pseudotropheus socolofi and Haplochromis ahli
Article
inNorth American Journal of Aquaculture 66(4):285-292 · October 2004 

Abstract
A 12-week feeding trial was conducted to evaluate growth performance and hepatocyte changes in juvenile African cichlids Pseudotropheus socolofi and Haplochromis ahli fed commercial diets commonly used on cichlid farms in south Florida. Fish were fed either a trout starter pellet diet (TP diet; 52% crude protein, 17% lipid) or a mixed flake feed diet (fish flake [FF] diet) (47% crude protein, 7% lipid). For both species, growth was significantly greater (P < 0.05) in fish fed the TP diet than in fish fed the FF diet, H. ahli administered the FF diet exhibiting the slowest growth. The hepatosomatic index was not significantly different among treatments (P > 0.1). Histological examination revealed severe vacuolation of hepatocytes in P. socolofi fed the TP diet and moderate vacuolation in H. ahli fed the TP diet. Moderate vacuolation of hepatocytes was observed in P. socolofi fed the FF diet, and only mild vacuolation was found in H. ahli fed the FF diet. The lipid-rich TP diet may be suitable for commercial production of juvenile African cichlids up to 12 weeks of age, but prolonged feeding may result in excess lipid deposition and necrosis of the liver. Feeds like the FF diet, which produced slower growth but lower lipid deposition in livers, may be more suitable as a maintenance diet for cichlids in the home aquarium.
 
I have to over feed my bass in order to get the proper proportions to my rays. All my fish are growing steady and I am changing out water on a daily to keep up with everything.
I have the same problem with my 2 kels. As matter of fact Luther is now about 10" and starting to punish the smaller kel. So much waste from large feedings and tissue damage to smaller kel I had change water (including sump) after 3 days and vac gravel. Added some salt and vitamins.
Anyway, sometimes there are reasons you have to feed a lot. Also with geos. Oscars and SD's get most of the food but geos gotta eat too.
Whether poop or uneaten food I am really a so called "follower" of Duanes opinions. Everytime I clean and change water I see improvement with the fish and plants.
 
I have the same problem with my 2 kels. As matter of fact Luther is now about 10" and starting to punish the smaller kel. So much waste from large feedings and tissue damage to smaller kel I had change water (including sump) after 3 days and vac gravel. Added some salt and vitamins.
Anyway, sometimes there are reasons you have to feed a lot. Also with geos. Oscars and SD's get most of the food but geos gotta eat too.
Whether poop or uneaten food I am really a so called "follower" of Duanes opinions. Everytime I clean and change water I see improvement with the fish and plants.
PS- Food is the only thing that seems to calm Luther down.
 
This is from a past discussion that another member posted about his poly that was eating too much, in his mixed tank.
Can you link us to the thread this quote was taken from ?
 
Yeah, why? You don't know how to use the search feature, Frank?
 
Only thing I would add on this thread is that some fish are more messy than others. And yes, I think that uneaten food tends to be more problematic.
 
All food becomes problematic when fed in excess, even when digested, waste is produced.
 
Yeah, why? You don't know how to use the search feature, Frank?
I have to search every one of your comments ? No i dont have ththe slightest clue on how to search for a thread when i dont have the title. Since you quoted it you must have it handy.... cmon throw us lesser beings a bone and just link it
 
I have to search every one of your comments ? No i dont have ththe slightest clue on how to search for a thread when i dont have the title. Since you quoted it you must have it handy.... cmon throw us lesser beings a bone and just link it
Agreed. Sounds like an interesting thread. I'm sure RD can refer. I would like to see it.
 
I'm at work, time is limited. search necrosis, and my user ID. Should get you to where you want.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com