Elk Antler in tank = BAD idea

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

JasonsPlecosCichlids

Goliath Tigerfish
MFK Member
Jan 23, 2010
3,613
1,630
179
44
Kentucky
jasonsplecoscichlids.com
Since I got my new tank, I added an elk antler, it was a shed I got from EBAY. I go through the same normal process of starting a new tank, new cycle, etc. I’ve had this tank for a while now, and I watched my tank cycle, but the ammonia is still higher than normal, around the 2.0 range. I do water changes every single day, twice on weekends. Well this past weekend I decided to do a 75% water change and I also decided to take out the antler as I got bored with it. The rays just moved it around wherever they wanted it anyways. I have also noticed a very foul smell from the tank and thought it was the bio-boost, cloudy, another reason why I wanted to change a lot of water. So I get about 50% drained and take the antler out, as I’m getting it out that foul smell just tripled, nastiest smell, made me gag. I tossed it outside on the porch. So I continued with the water change, filled back up, and just did another water change last night because the smell was still there. I also cleaned out the 3 FX5’s, they didn’t smell any better. So after I got done I took something to the porch, I found a place to hang the antler in my apartment, as I got closer I could still smell it, like it was rotting. Then I noticed that it was bleeding from two of the tips, a lot of blood was coming from the tip of one of the tines and some from the first tine. I read online that it needs to be soaked in water for about a month so the liquids can escape, add salt to the water, etc. I filled up the tub, added a ton of salt, but the smell was just too much. I out it back out on the porch, still need to decide what to do with it.


All this time I thought I was having water issues when all it was, was the antler. It was been rotting in my tank, bleeding out blood and other liquids, lost a few fish in the process and wasted a lot of water. Here are the photos below.

IMAG0104.jpg


IMAG0105.jpg
 
Sorry but this needs to be said.... why not read up what to do before adding something organic like antlers to your tank, not after?
 
Ugh I would be pissed if that happened all I gotta say is I'm
Not adding anything like antlers to any of my tanks.
 
Sorry but this needs to be said.... why not read up what to do before adding something organic like antlers to your tank, not after?

I did, lots of people add deer antlers to their tanks, one thread came from here I think doing a Google search.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com