Experiment time! Cruel or Not?

[Dylan]

Hold on. Why are you giving up so easy? We dont know for sure that it will kill the BB. Try it guinea pig! lol

I do know for sure it will kill the BB. Silver kills single celled organisms within seconds of contact with it. A constantly cycled tank full of silver nano particles is going to destroy all bacterial life in that tank, good or bad.

Don't try and convince him otherwise, if your so keen to it, try it on your own tank, guinea pig.

 

[David R]

Could always give it a bath in silver once a week...




or just appreciate your fish for what they are rather than trying to make them into something else. If you want more colour go buy some abstract art or a stained glass window or something....

 

[sodenoshirayuki]

Hold on. Why are you giving up so easy? We dont know for sure that it will kill the BB. Try it guinea pig! lol

Why don't you go be a gunea pig and inject yourself with sample drugs to see if it will kill you or not. Try it out, lets see how you like it.

 

[selki]

Why don't you go be a gunea pig and inject yourself with sample drugs to see if it will kill you or not. Try it out, lets see how you like it.

Lol.. he wouldnt understand... so why are we even thinking of dying something not meant to? why dont u dye your whole back blue and just look in the mirror?

 

[SOKO]

Although collodial silver is actually healthy for people in certain ways. It is debatable about how healthy it actually is when drinking it pure. It is very possible that a fish could die.

Just my own two cents.

But if you can get your hands on a cheap silver aro (could even be a runt) just to experiment and see. Eventually progress to a nice and healthy silver.

 

[sodenoshirayuki]

Seriously if you decide to go through with it, get a silver from golden garden. Theres like 20, 6' in a 10 gallon tank. Might as well get one there and if it happens to kill it atleast it doesn't need to swim in a 10 gallon anymore.