Female xilo and sagittae Q

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Natalie

Jack Dempsey
MFK Member
Aug 31, 2007
1,552
0
36
Florida
I'm pretty unfamiliar with Amphilophus xiloaensis and sagittae... can anyone tell me the maximum size of females for both of these species?

:)
 
Hi there.....I have both at the moment and they are very different fish..IMO
the Sag's are very aggresive and are growing rapidly...kind of like a Midas
on steroides....they are a contender to other heavy weight cichlids...
the xilo's seem a little more fancy and the snouts on the two species are def. defferent...Xil'o more long and thin & Sag's more larger and not as long...
I like them both but I would say Sag's are more heavy weights than Xil'os and might grow a bit larger.....but the answer to your question is; they should both grow to about 10 to 12 inches for females.....and Sag's would
be bigger than xil's.....Heavy weight tank....go with Sag's....middle weight
tank...go with xilo's....
just my 2 cents......cheers
 
terrors r us;5009434;5009434 said:
Hi there.....I have both at the moment and they are very different fish..IMO
the Sag's are very aggresive and are growing rapidly...kind of like a Midas
on steroides....they are a contender to other heavy weight cichlids...
the xilo's seem a little more fancy and the snouts on the two species are def. defferent...Xil'o more long and thin & Sag's more larger and not as long...
I like them both but I would say Sag's are more heavy weights than Xil'os and might grow a bit larger.....but the answer to your question is; they should both grow to about 10 to 12 inches for females.....and Sag's would
be bigger than xil's.....Heavy weight tank....go with Sag's....middle weight
tank...go with xilo's....
just my 2 cents......cheers
i believe xiloaensis are more similiar to midas they get more bulk and grow decent sized nuchual humps i have a male xiloansis atm.....
heres a male xilo

 
very nice fish!!!!! you might have a point there...they do look more like midas...
here are some of mine....

the sag:
New Pikes 001.jpg

the sag again:New Pikes 002.jpg

the xilo's, guy in the middle:
New Pikes 003.jpg

the three on the right are xilo's....one on the left is sag:
New Pikes 004.jpg

when did your xilo turn white????
 
i'm starting to wonder if this is just a selling gimick?
yes they could come from different rivers but at the end of the day...just a midas or labiatus.....why the big expense???
 
Thank you all for the info and pics! I was hoping that the females of either species would stay small (7-8 inches or so). I guess they get larger than that. I'm so desperate to have an Amphilophus in my house but just don't have room for a Midas/RD. Oh well. I'll have to be patient!
 
Natalie;5009700;5009700 said:
Thank you all for the info and pics! I was hoping that the females of either species would stay small (7-8 inches or so). I guess they get larger than that. I'm so desperate to have an Amphilophus in my house but just don't have room for a Midas/RD. Oh well. I'll have to be patient!
the only amphilophus i can think of that stays smaller would be Red Isetas..... they seem to stay smaller around 8" i havent seen one bigger but i might be wrong the only person to carry these is Jeff Rappa
 
Natalie;5009700; said:
Thank you all for the info and pics! I was hoping that the females of either species would stay small (7-8 inches or so). I guess they get larger than that. I'm so desperate to have an Amphilophus in my house but just don't have room for a Midas/RD. Oh well. I'll have to be patient!

Why not try a lyonsi? Pretty sure they don't get bigger than that, and a beautiful fish.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com