Filter selection

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

ogre929

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Dec 25, 2005
303
1
0
47
England
I've been in the fish hobby for a good dozen years or so and I used to primarily use canister filters after i got rid of my power filters. But in recent years of doing freshwater on the side of my reef tanks, I primarily use wet dry filters. They're much easier to clean, maintain, and if you build em right you can put all your extra crap in there too, carbon, heaters and whatever else you so desire. Though after reading through this section and most of the rest of the forum I've discovered that a lot of people here really like to use cannister filters and I'm curious why? They were always pretty expensive and a pain in the arse to clean. I built my wet dry filters out of rubbermaid tubs and instant ocean 6 gal buckets and some bio balls and it worked great. I put it together for next to nothing. I think the most expensive part was the bio balls. Not including the pump or the overflow box. I'm pretty set on my next tank having a built in overflow and running my sumps. What's everyone elses opinion on filtration for large freshwater fish. Or any freshwater fish for that matter.

DSC01171.JPG

DSC01170.JPG
 
wet/dry rules! I've got a big one on my 300 and i love it....Its an odd setup, check my gallery if you care to see!........wet/dry all the way:)
 
that is an odd setup but looks pretty sweet!
 
People seem to like canisters until they try wet/dry sumps ;)

Canisters appear simple for most people, all they see is an IN hose, an OUT hose and a canister full of filter media, whereas a sump looks complicated and awkward. In reality its probably the opposite! I have built a sump for one of my tanks to replace a canister and never looked back! I am now building another sump filter for a new tank.l For half the price of a canister filter I can build a sump that will have 3x the filtering power ;)

Canisters do have advantages in certain appilcations, they tend to be quieter and being enclosed, humidity and evaporation is not a problem.
 
i love em.. never anything but w.d as my main filters now
 
I took a 6 gal salt bucket and drilled holes on all sides of the bottom 1/5th of the bucket. Inside is a pvc stand where i cut eggcrate (the plastic kind) to fit in the bottom of the bucket. filled it with bio balls and at the top was a plastic tray for plants. I cut a lot of holes in it and put filter media in it. And put the lid on. Pretty darn simple. took about an hour to build. Getting the egg crate to the right size was the most time consuming part. Then cut a hole in the top in slits so that the hose could squeeze in in a press fit. That way it doesn't fall out. Then I placed the bucket (wet dry filter) in a big rubber maid tub with a big rio pump and my heater and filled it with water then plugged everything in. super easy and damn was it cheap.
 
the egg crate was a good 4 inches off the bottom just to keep most of the bio balls out of the water and to keep it from floating away. but i'm sure you could just fill it all the way up with bio balls instead.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com