Filtration on a budget help

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
knicks791;3742120; said:
Spending 220 (FX5)+ 35 (bio media) is worth not having to dealing with DIY wet/dry IMO.

But will agree that wet/dry > fx5 in regards to filtration.


So other than sheer laziness, why would you prefer to spend more money & get less filtration?
 
ive decided to plan a DIY/Custom sump rather than on FX5's.

I figure a well designed sump will be easier to service than the the canister, cost aside.
 
Fishman0;3745347; said:
ive decided to plan a DIY/Custom sump rather than on FX5's.

I figure a well designed sump will be easier to service than the the canister, cost aside.


True. If you're not careful, you may even save yourself some cash!
 
JakeH;3745381; said:
True. If you're not careful, you may even save yourself some cash!


Haha thats always a good thing.

Im going to make it as simple and serviceable as possible.

Time to do some research
 
The drawer system works great I hear. Thats what I'm doing. I already built the sump out of a 18g rubbermaid ($4) using a Sterilite 3-drawer organizer ($3) and a few $1 baskets from the same aisle of wal-mart. Just finished drilling drip-plate holes in the drawers & filling them with spare media. Trying to figure out which DIY overflow design to go with now. I cant remember which thread I got the 3-drawer thing from, but I think it was called "cheapest wet/dry ever" or something like that...
 
A way to simplify is to make the sump into an above the tank dump filter. Instead of overflowing water from a sump down into a sump and pumping with several feet
of head back into the tank... You simply pump water from the tank into a sump (rubbermaids) sitting on top of your tank and allow gravity to return the water to the tank via holes in the bottom of the sump.

Apart from not having to dork with diy overflows, you get a lot more flow out of your pumps. Pumping 1 or 2 foot or so into a dump filter will give you much more flow than pumping up 5 feet from a floor level sump

Matt
 
dogofwar;3745564; said:
A way to simplify is to make the sump into an above the tank dump filter. Instead of overflowing water from a sump down into a sump and pumping with several feet
of head back into the tank... You simply pump water from the tank into a sump (rubbermaids) sitting on top of your tank and allow gravity to return the water to the tank via holes in the bottom of the sump.

Apart from not having to dork with diy overflows, you get a lot more flow out of your pumps. Pumping 1 or 2 foot or so into a dump filter will give you much more flow than pumping up 5 feet from a floor level sump

Matt


In theory it makes perfect sense. Do you have anywhere i can find plans on this?

I can imagine it to be similar to some pond filters, but above a tank is new to me.

wont this design need additional support structures?
 
You basically get a rubbermaids that fits on your tank...and/or use a strip or two of 1" by 2" wood for support

the basic design is to get a rubbermaids and drill three holes in the bottom: one for water in via a pump in the tank and two holes for drains.

Whatever you choose to put in the bin for filtration is up to you. I've usef three drawer bins, plastic fast food baskets, bio balls, whatever...

I prefer the under the bed style rubbermaids

Matt
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com