regardless of the soul comment tbh it is his fish and as long as he didn't do any real physical damage it's nobodys business to judge him, hell even if he did hurt it, still nobody's business but his own
I won't get into my beliefs about "souls". I'll just say this, the life of a human is worth no more than the life of a fish. Don't get me wrong, I'm not some PETA vegan weirdo. I'm just saying, the only difference between us and a fish is some lines of DNA.
i love fish to but im not going to call someone cruel for hitting there fish. my dog was attacking a cat the other day and i hit it to save the cats life am i cruel?