Flake food vs pellet

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
I have heard that sinking pellets are better for fish as it is a more natural way to feed. As a side note I also heard that floating pellets are thought to contribute to swim bladder issues in some fish, an interesting thought i.m.o.

Interesting. I haven't had that issue but I only feed the floating pellets when I have to. Right now, I am keeping mostly South American cichlids which all take sinking pellets.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tlindsey
Which species?

Earth Eaters!

In the process of restocking the 20g so all that is in there now is a young pair of G. dacrya and a handful of tetras. Up until recently it held groups of G. winemilleri and Uaru, a big group of rummynose and a 6" L330.

I have a group of 12 4" G. altifrons coming this week.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tlindsey
Earth Eaters!

In the process of restocking the 20g so all that is in there now is a young pair of G. dacrya and a handful of tetras. Up until recently it held groups of G. winemilleri and Uaru, a big group of rummynose and a 6" L330.

I have a group of 12 4" G. altifrons coming this week.
Wow, keep it updated post pics
 
  • Like
Reactions: dalto and tlindsey
I only feed flake to my sparkling gourami and tetras, they clean up well if I feed sparsely. I think even crushed granules would be better

General consensus is that pellets are better, and I agree
 
I have heard that sinking pellets are better for fish as it is a more natural way to feed. As a side note I also heard that floating pellets are thought to contribute to swim bladder issues in some fish, an interesting thought i.m.o.

I've only heard of gulping too much air and causing swimming bladder with goldfish. I've fed floating pellets to many cichlids and have never had swimming bladder issues in over 20 years.

Some fish naturally eat food from the surface, which is one of the reasons for their mouths to be turned upwards. (e.g. oscar)
 
  • Like
Reactions: tlindsey
The amount of "dust" that my flakes create is the reason I'm starving my Haitiensis until they start eating pellets. My filter floss in my sump was dark brown from the flakes and dust all spread throughout the sump.
 
The amount of "dust" that my flakes create is the reason I'm starving my Haitiensis until they start eating pellets. My filter floss in my sump was dark brown from the flakes and dust all spread throughout the sump.
This is my exact issue, the sludge gets quite nasty.
 
Even for the smallest of fry, in today's market micro pellets are available, and of course one can crush larger pellets into dust sized particles using an electric coffee grinder, or mortar and pestle.

Flakes lose their nutrient content, especially water soluble nutrients such as vitamin c, very quickly once they enter an aquarium.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jhay3513
MonsterFishKeepers.com