Is this fish going into a tank by themselves? I'm assuming you are wanting a solitary wet pet. In addition to what everyone else has already said, the other factor is, what do you like the look of better? Since you are only getting one fish, and since personality is situational fish to fish, what fish would you rather look at for the years ahead? I have a pied bald red devil who is super cool. Cool personality, also pretty mean, but fun and a good looking fish. Not that I regret buying my devil, but if it came down to it and I had the option and access to get either a red devil or flowerhorn as a solitary wet pet, I would get a flowerhorn. Either way, I don't think you will regret it. Both great fish! Good luck.