Fresh caught vs. Bait store feeders

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

ewurm

Aimara
MFK Member
Jan 27, 2006
28,496
79
132
16
*
The bait store feeders are not very hardy and i end up picking deads out of the tank constantly. The minnows I catch usually make it and thrive in the tank until eaten. Have you had a similar experience or have an opinion?
 
The feeders I buy from the bait store a few miles from me sells 50 for $3.05, and I put all 50 in a 10 gallon walmart tank with a filter but no heater and they lasted over a week without food. They seem to do better in colder water. The ones I get last forever and take no maintance, but they are very fast and know how to jump haha.
 
thats because they come from crowded tanks high in ammonia and usally full of meds high in coppers trying to keep them alive feeders are riddled with parasites i wouldnt ever use one again SandTiger wrote a great article about feeders should pm him and see if he'll post it here would make a good sticky
 
i go through the same thing as ewurm always picking out dead ones and ones that have chunks missing out of them i think they put them through a meatgrinder before they sell them :confused:
 
fishnutham said:
thats because they come from crowded tanks high in ammonia and usally full of meds high in coppers trying to keep them alive feeders are riddled with parasites i wouldnt ever use one again SandTiger wrote a great article about feeders should pm him and see if he'll post it here would make a good sticky

I read it but I don't think my LMB will eat pellets and I can't afford enough krill, ghost shrimp, or bloodworms to keep him happy. Besides, watching him devour other fish is the reason to have a bass. I might try and find another source for feeders in the winter.
 
ewurm said:
I read it but I don't think my LMB will eat pellets and I can't afford enough krill, ghost shrimp, or bloodworms to keep him happy. Besides, watching him devour other fish is the reason to have a bass. I might try and find another source for feeders in the winter.


grab a spare tank and breed some goldfish lot of people do it that way not worth losing a prized fish because of the crap they sell to people these days.
 
I have heard that is difficult...details please.
 
i havent bred goldies my self just danios and some neons i used them for my oscar for a treat i'll find some info for ya though oh you could strike a deal with a lfs and buy the common goldfish intended for display i know the bigals i deal with would sell me a case if i wanted when they order theyre shipments its not as cheap as feeders but they are cleaner.


i know its sounds hard but its not really buy mature fish and make sure your tanks big enough best part is one spawning will do for a year comets drop a lot of eggs
 
Breeding Goldfish


Goldfish mature at about 1 yr; however, they are in their prime about their 3rd year. A male that is ready to spawn will usually have tubercles about pin size that appear on the pectoral fins and gill covers. However, this does not always occur and has been seen in some females. (see photo of tubercles on male fish)

Temperatures should be about 700F. during the day and 500F. at night. You will notice the spawning chase occur. The male will begin chasing the female for two to three hours, bumping into her abdomen. If she is ready eggs will spurt out and stick to the first thing they come in contact with. They are usually released in batches with the first batch being the best. The male fertilizes the eggs immediately by spraying milt over them. Good sized females can lay anywhere from 500-1000 eggs a spawn.

Goldfish usually spawn in warm waters in the morning sun

You should remove the eggs immediately and rinse them in a bucket of aged water that is the same temperature as the tank they were removed from. Your goldfish eggs should be kept in water that is not deeper than 6 inches. In deeper water the pressure can damage the fry and make it hard for them to reach the surface. After rinsing the eggs place them in a 20 gallon tank. You should raise the temperature to about 700F. The fish will hatch in 3-4 days. By the end of the first day you will notice that some eggs are clear tan to yellow while some are white. The ones that appear almost clear are the ones that are fertile. The others are more than likely infertile and will be subject to fungus. The fungused eggs should be removed immediately, or the fungus can spread to kill the other eggs.

Some breeders add a few drops of methylene blue to the water to cut down on the fungus occurence.

The fish will hatch out along the region of his back, pulling his tail out first, then moving it to release its head. At birth the fish is about a 16th of an inch to an 8th of an inch long with two black eyes, a long notochord, and a full yolk sac. These transluscent fry should not be disturbed. Do not be alarmed if they fall to the bottom. Within 48 hrs of hatching they will have absorbed their yolk sacs and an air bladder and rudimentary pectoral fin will become noticeable. After about 48 hours they're air bladders will fill and they will start swimming normally seeking food. They will eat anything they can fit into their mouths. This is when it becomes important to have some food on hand.

See chart below for feeding instructions

Feeding the babies can be somewhat troublesome since they are so small. You must be sure to place enough food in the water that they can find it, but no too much to pollute the water. Keeping a continous supply is needed. It is best to remove the uneaten food within a few hours and add more. Doing this helps maintain the water conditions. These little guys will grow rapidly and soon be requiring a lot of food.

As the fish grow you will need to place them in larger tanks or divide them into tanks.
 
In the winter, you could always use crickets or mealworms. Also, you could build a compost pile and keep your bass in earthworms. Market shrimp are also fairly cheap. If you buy the broken shrimp pieces you will probably pay less than 3 dollars a pound, which will last a long time.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com