I don't think anyone was flaming. Giving honest answers to a question, maybe, but letting someone know that a particular fish
will get a certain size.. .I don't see that as flaming. And no one is stopping him from putting whichever fish he wants into his tanks. Also, it could save him trouble later if those fish
do get big faster than he anticipated. It could be worse. . . The Wal-Mart in my town has a picture of a pacu in 55 in their fish dept. The fish is like 2'+ !
As for an answer to the question at hand, texas, Jack dempsey, cuban cichlids would work in a 55 by themselves. Personally, I have seen numerous photos of GT's reaching 10-11". One thing I do to decide what fish to put in my tanks is to take a tape measure to the end of the tank, and measure the distance
on the inside of the glass. I think most people will agree that most tanks actually have about 1"
less space on the inside. Bottom line, if the fish is healthy, who cares? There's a video on youtube of a guy who had a 12" oscar in a 30G, and the fish was perfectly healthy. He later moved it o a larger tnak though.
