Goonch/TSN/Dorado $50-200- Dayton, OH, PU only

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Status
Not open for further replies.
I think you got a fricken deal on the fish. I myself like to transport fish with 50% new water with tank water. I've had more success like this then 100% old tank water. As long as the temperature was not super cold. 50 gallons should of been more then plenty of water to transport the 2 fish. But to fill a 150g stock tank! I don't think it was needed. That's a lot of water splashing around.
 
75 gallons or so of water is not a lot to ask for. He wasn't expecting the seller to fill up 150 gallons of water. The buyer and seller, as fish keepers should do whatever possible to make sure the fish has a great ride home. Not just take money and say good luck getting the fish home with 25 gallons of water. I've sold many fish to Josh and others and always give anyone as much water that is needed. It's no different than performing a water change so the stress issue use a useless argument. He may have got a good deal but that deal is only good if the fish make it home safely, not with just approx. 25 gallons of water. Just an FYI, a large tote or two that was expected to be brought to the deal would use more water than was given to Josh. $300 for one fish is not chump change. He was texting me after the ordeal, pretty sad.
 
This was clearly a mis-understanding and the communication should have been better from the start. Calling names and throwing out a threat is very immature. Especially if the fish made it OK. Sending negative feedback on a deal that seemed flawless other than the amount of water available is also questionable. This is suprising from seasoned members.
 
Well here another note I was the one that was purchasing the fishes from this guy at first... when I called him was kinda rude.... I was trading some big dats for them and decided not too but on the phone he was kinda rude and I talked to my wife and decided not to do business with him I was going to drive 5 hours there and 5 hours back I offered him more money to meet halfway he said hell no... I was iffy in the begining and was iffy now so I belive the story about the water even texting him was kinda rude on even text so I'm glad I didn't make the trip I treat everyone with respect and always try to make both parties happy but this guy was all about him anyway thought I let you guys know why I didn't pick them up in the begining ....

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I717 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
 
This was clearly a mis-understanding and the communication should have been better from the start. Calling names and throwing out a threat is very immature. Especially if the fish made it OK. Sending negative feedback on a deal that seemed flawless other than the amount of water available is also questionable. This is suprising from seasoned members.
I agree fish made it home ok why the bashing. No harm no foul
 
dont let this guy sway anyones thoughts, he was real helpfull untill he got the cash,

also it was 4 fish a 1' dorado, a 2' goonch a 2' tiger shovelnose and a ornate bicher, and yes we had a 150 gallon rubbermaid tub, but we only wanted to fill it half way, i have it set up with a filter that runs on it so just in case we have a breakdown or something else went wrong and the fish had to stay in there over night then it would be no problem, we had air pumps and battery operated air pumps with extra batteries, for other things that might go wrong,
now josh only put in about 2- 1/2 inches of water when the guy said that was all he was going to let him have, josh was surprised and ended up getting upset, because we did not have the means to use fresh water because the guy offered a hose (the water was cold out of it, we also did not have another tub to put water in and add dechlor) so all josh wanted was a little more water to cover the fish's back, and i dont care what the guy is saying , he walked away and went inside saying he was done with this, now he had a 300 gallon tank, he could of ran the hose to the and filled his tank as it emptied out, but instead we had to put the fish in hardly no water and then add chlorinated cold as hell water and then add dechlor to our tub of fish that were already stressed from moving them out of there tank and into this tub with hardly any water from there own tank, we have been on hundreds of fish runs and we have never had to deal with this kind of thing,
anyone that buys fish from me gets treated with plenty of respect, i give them all the water they need and i have even given people a battery operated air pump because they showed up unprepared, i have printed out maps, i have fed people and there families and even drank with other people that showed up, that is what is expected from seasoned fish keepers, we are here to help each other in our hobby, but first and foremost you help the fish, not argue over 25- 50 gallons of water, josh would of helped him, but instead my son was left to fend for himself and put the fish at risk, he stopped at a few gas stations on the way home and filled bucket by bucket of warm water from the bathroom sinks and dechlored it and it took him 2-1/2 hours to get there and 4 hours to get home, he arrived at 1:30 in the morning and then i took over acclimating and taking care of everything because he had school in the morning, so if the guy would of givin josh the 50 gallons he needed, and filled his 300 back up, josh would not of had to spend all that time on the trip home, as he left that guys house with the backs of the fish out of the water, plain and simple, ive done this for years and never ran into this situaltion before, we actually had a real prick of a guy once that would not let us in his house and would not open his front door, he handed us the hose through a window and handed the fish out to us through a window and treated us with a real attitude, but even he made shure the fish had enough water, anyways the fish made it home, and as always anyone that wants to stop by and see the fish are more than welcome, just pm me first to set it up, we have over 10,000 gallons of setups full of fish,
thanks
bigrich
 
But I guess you are missing the point... maybe because its never happened to you bit I completely understand where bigrich is commimg from.....

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I717 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
MonsterFishKeepers.com