I think a 55 would be a great grow-out, but 75 or larger would eventually be necessary, due to the eventual possible size of 12" (a 55 gallon is only 12" wide)
If you absolutely don't see yourself upgrading the tank, I would get another cichlid that stays a bit smaller and would be comfortable in the 55 gallon. Hericthys Deppi or Bartoni are two highly aggressive cichlids which stay about 8-9", and a nice big male would make a good solo monster fish for this tank.
If you absolutely don't see yourself upgrading the tank, I would get another cichlid that stays a bit smaller and would be comfortable in the 55 gallon. Hericthys Deppi or Bartoni are two highly aggressive cichlids which stay about 8-9", and a nice big male would make a good solo monster fish for this tank.