Have you ever..

[alcohologist]

nah, I couldn't eat something that I once cared for

if by cared for you mean had a bond with, then yeah.
but if by cared for you mean owned/reared, then i dont see what the big deal is. if it's a healthy fish and you're so inclined, why not?

 

[SumoNinja]

nah, not with all the chemicals we use in the water,..........

 

[packer43064]

I hear their squishy so nah.

 

[Heavyarm7]

Chemicals are a good point. But prolly couldn't be any worse then waking down the frozen tv dinner isle.

 

[bloodoftheshark]

I hate to sound like an ass but a fish is a fish, The puppy drum I caught out of the ocean was tasty as fish in foil, fish chowder and fish and chips so if it so happened that I had to eat a fish, sure why not.

 

[Fish_Savy :3]

thats like eating your own child :O

 

[Heavyarm7]

I hear their squishy so nah.

Packer who ate their fish you know of? Haha

 

[Ang]

had a big tinfoil barb that was driving me crazy. he would splash at all hours of the night. bang around on stuff. i think he was retarded.

i thought about eating him.......... but i didnt

 

[channarox]

yes...many times.
ive actually eaten pbass before,pretty good.
barras too.

 

[Bottomfeeder]

You guys would be surprised. Do a quick search for "CentralMayhem" in the MFK search bar.
And when I used to keep Ghost Shrimp, I was always temped, after seeing the Survivorman episode where he catches River Shrimp out of a drainage pool and eats them. And I even thought about the Pleco once, because Amazonian Indians catch big Plecos, kill them, then toss them into an open flame; then they crack the fish open and scoop the meat out.