I use the true temp titanium shielded heaters for one of my ponds, 2 of the 1000W models plugged into a reef keeper controller. Didn't like the 2 degree temp swings that the controllers they come with have. I agree you would be better off with 2 500W in your case than 1 1000W. Heaters do go out from time to time, always best to have a backup to prevent the temp from falling to much.