I thought the same thing at first too, but what was interesting is that all of the fish (20+ of them) had these same exact markings (they ranged in size from 1.5" to 2.5"). The fish in the pic above is about 2.75". Every time I've seen a group of juvenile RD's or Midas for sale, there is quite a variety in the colors (some are fading, some are still barred, and some are orange). Although you're probably right, I'm anxious to see what colors he/she starts to exhibit as it matures.