I can buy the Amberjack, with the line through it's eye. The barring looked a little off to me, but I haven't caught one in a while. I really need to get the boat out more.
As far as the Redfish, definitely one of those, and the croaker that you see is in the same family, so they do look very similar, but the black spot, as noted before, is the giveaway.
The first is definitely a red drum (redfish sciaenops ocelatus). The second fish is a member of the jack family that i think is a banded rudderfish. It looks like a small amberjack, but there are a few differnces.