HELP! Is my tank going to explode?!

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Good to hear. Had an intensely long week with work/school, and capped it off with an all nighter working on more school/murals/writing. Read a thread about exploding tanks and realized mine wasnt exactly flawless. @_@ straws and backs. Time for sleep.
Godspeed, friends.
 
Looks fine to me too that ply looks thick its strong stuff with a little overhang like that it won't bow , nice mural :cool::thumbup:I'd love to see that once finished perhaps you could post it in my artwork thread ;):D

Sent from my Nexus 7 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
 
Hello; From looking at the pictures I do not see the issue you decscribe. I cannot tell that the tank is positioned on the stand in a risky way. Without images that show it in a different way you will have to use your best judgment. Take advice from these forumns about do's and dont's with care. You are the one actually on site and have the best view.

Taking down a large tank and re-setting it is a chore. I have done such to get more peace of mind. If you do decide to re-set the tank you might consider removing what appears to be a rug from under the stand. My experience is that tanks on rugs or carpet leads to problems. I will no longer place a tank on a carpet or rug.

good luck
 
I don't build tables, but this is my understanding of the situation. In the first place, we can accept that the tank isn't set where the stand designers rated it to work. That doesn't mean it will fail immediately, soon or ever. It does mean that failure is more likely than had it been set properly, but we don't how much more likely it is.

It's difficult to say without knowing how the stand is designed. Per your post, it's basically 4 pillars with 4 connecting beams (the "rectangle") covered by a table top that extends beyond the rectangle on all sides. The top could also be essentially a single welded piece of metal.

Normally, I'd want the top and the beams to be acting in concert to distribute load directly to the pillars, however they don't have to be designed that way. In one case, the beams could be primarily for stability. If the table top actually has only 4 points of contact and those are the pillars (legs), then the beams aren't carrying much load (if any) and the table top is meant to do all the work of distributing the load evenly. On the other hand, if the beams are on top of the pillars or set to run at the same height as the pillars (and possibly reinforced with angles from the pillars), or if the top is a single welded piece sitting on top of the pillars, then the beams are engaged as well in taking load and transferring it to the pillars. This is probably how it was done and the beams are therefore distributing load.

In the latter case, you probably are fine as most of the tank's load is being carried elsewhere. On that questionable edge, the beams and table top are being subjected to some "extra" shear force that could have been avoided by proper placement, but it's probably small as the tabletop is conveying a lot of load across all of the beams.

In the former case, the tabletop alone is taking extra shear force and then it might depend on the strength of the table top. That doesn't mean it will fail, since the force is being directed to a relatively small area.
 
Thanks, Monsieur Strangelove. Here are some pictures of the inside of the stand:

Keep in mind these pictures are turned 90 degrees to the left.

CAM02777.jpg
CAM02778.jpg

There arent any "beams" per say. There are, however, three 2 by 4's that I am assuming are meant to distribute the load.

CAM02777.jpg

CAM02778.jpg
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com